Page 97

“Oh, hell yes, Annie,” Ben whispers, and he puts his hand around the tip of her tail, helping guide it inside her pussy. I can’t imagine how good the view is from his angle, because his eyes grow even wider as he watches her fuck herself, while still keeping her mouth around his cock. After a minute, he shakes himself from the hypnosis and starts sucking her clit, which sends her right over the edge again. She releases his cock and practically screams both our names when she comes. I’m still fucking Ben, but watching the two of them like this only pushes me closer and closer, so I reach out and seize Annie by the throat again. I’m not nearly as gentle this time, squeezing another loud cry from her as the second orgasm rocks her body.

“Fuck, Annie, you’re doing so well. You’re being such a good girl,” I tell her. “I can’t believe how fucking beautiful you are when he makes you come, but I need one more from you. One more. Can you do that for me, sweetheart?” She keeps her eyes shut and nods, then her fingers close around my wrist as she shudders one last time and goes slightly limp. Ben continues groaning beneath me, so I push him harder, my thrusts becoming rougher and more insistent.

“Do you remember what else I need from you?” I ask breathlessly.

“Yes,” Annie whispers, her voice hoarse. “Ben, my love, you will want to watch this.” She opens her eyes and the devious little sparkle returns as she swings her tail back around and takes the tip between her hands. I keep a tight grip on her throat and watch as she reshapes it into a delicate, blunt taper, about the width of her thumb. Then, she reaches over and grabs the bottle of lube from the bed. I slow my pace and Ben lets out a long breath, tilting his chin down to see what Annie is doing.

“Oh, Theo…” he murmurs, and our eyes meet. I give him a wide smile, as well as another hard thrust, and he drops his head with a moan. Once Annie’s tail is ready, she wraps it around my hips and slides over my tailbone.

“Breathe, Theo,” she says softly, gripping my wrist with my hand still around her throat. I can’t look at her, can’t let myself feel too much, so I look down at Ben instead, holding his gaze as the tip of Annie’s tail teases and prods for a moment, then slides inside me. I groan, release her throat, and fall forward so my head presses into Ben’s ribs. I never imagined anything could feel this fucking good. Being inside him, having her inside me. It’s ecstasy. Pure fucking ecstasy that I’ll never recover from.

“Is this alright, love?” Annie asks gently, brushing her fingers against my cheek.

“Yes,” I gasp. “God, yes. Don’t stop.” She moves her tail gently, slowly, a little at a time until I’ve adjusted, and I can resume my own movements, which send Ben into a spiral. He moans my name over and over again, grabbing onto my arms as his back arches. I can tell he’s about to come, so I wrench myself free from his grasp and straighten up, trying not to fall apart myself.

“One more, sweet Annie,” I tell her, then I grab her hair and guide her head down again so she can suck Ben’s cock. He puts his arms back around her thighs and resumes eating her out, then everything around me dissolves into a haze of moans and screams, jerking bodies, and bruising fingers digging into sweat-soaked flesh. Ben comes first, his entire body almost lifting off the mattress as I slam my cock into him one more time and let myself go, reaching back to grip Annie’s tail, keeping it inside me. He uses her thighs as leverage to slide himself back and forth on top of the sheets, pulling every last drop from my cock. Annie suddenly comes tooand collapses into me, our mouths somehow colliding through the fog.

The salty remnants of Ben’s cum tinge her kiss, but it looks like she spilled the rest of it onto his stomach. Her tail stays inside me for a moment longer as the orgasm works its way through my body, clenching every muscle in turn, then she withdraws. I pull out of Ben too, then collapse beside him on the bed. Breaths coming in tiny bursts edged with moans, Annie shuffles backwards and falls above our heads. Ben’s chest is heaving and I put my hand over his racing heart. He grabs it and brings each of my fingers to his lips in turn, then reaches behind my neck and pulls me in for a kiss that tastes entirely like Annie’s sweet pussy.

“That was…” he gasps, “that was just…”

Giggling, Annie inches down to drape her arm across his chest. “I do not think you were given permission to speak again,” she teases, and he pulls her into an upside down kiss.

“Well, then it’s a good thing you fucked the words right out of my mouth,” he says hoarsely when they break apart. He collapses back onto the mattress and closes his eyes, so I tilt my head back to look at Annie. She meets my gaze and gives me a sweet, if exhausted, smile.

No demon. Just my Annie.

Careful to keep my actual emotions under lock and key, I dare one more kiss, threading my fingers through her hair—my thirst for both of them completely and utterly quenched.

I wake up to the sound of my phone buzzing on the nightstand, but I’m feeling so blissful, I don’t even want to answer. It’s Sunday, my one day completely off from work, so I can only imagine it’s my mom calling to ask if I’m going to be at Mass and family lunch today. I can’t have that conversation with her when my demon girlfriend and ex-priest boyfriend are sleeping next to me, especially after what we did last night, so I just let it ring and open my eyes.

They’re both so funny when they sleep—mouths hanging wide open and arms thrown in every direction. I’ve been told I sleep in a tight ball, and that I look very serious, but these two don’t seem to have a care in the world. Ben is on his back with his arms above his head, snoring a little. Annie is sprawled beside him, drooling on his bicep, one hand tangled through his and one resting on his chest as it rises and falls. Rex has wedged himself between them, curled against Annie’s stomach with his head tucked under his tail. It’s the cutest fucking thing I’ve ever seen, but I have to keep my emotions in check. Being incredibly careful and slow, I reach back and grab my phone to take a picture. As soon as I snap it, however, another call comes through. It’s Aileen, my boss at the shelter. I already have two missed calls from her and a few texts, so I answer it, rolling over to sit on the edge of the bed.

“Hey, Aileen. Everything ok?”

“Oh, gosh, Theo, I am so sorry!” she says, her voice strained. “I know it’s your day off, and I hate to ask you this, but my ex had an emergency and I have to go pick my kid up two hours away. Is thereanyway you could go over to the shelter and do all the feedings and clean kennels this morning? I should be able to come in to do them this afternoon, but I have to get on the road ASAP.”

“Of course,” I tell her. “Yeah, that’s not a problem at all. Is it ok if I bring Ben and Annie to help me out?”

“That’s fine!” Aileen sighs, the relief in her voice audible. “Thank you so much, Theo! Obviously you’ll get paid, and I’ll make it up to you somehow, I promise! You’re the best!”

“Sure thing, Aileen. I’ve got my key. You just worry about your family.”

We say a quick goodbye, then I haul myself out of the bed and begin searching for work-appropriate clothing. I bought myself some scrubs just after starting, because they’re comfortable and easy to wash, but they’re all dirty today. Instead, I throw on a pair of ragged sweatpants and one of Ben’s band shirts that I find on the floor.

“Everything good,osito?” comes his still-raspy voice from behind me. I climb back onto the bed and crawl over him, lowering myself down to kiss his neck. His arms thread around me, pulling me into his little pool of warmth. If I could have only one thing guaranteed for the rest of my life, it would be to wake up like this every single morning.

“Please tell me I didn’t hallucinate everything that happened last night…” Ben murmurs against my lips.

“Oh, so youdidenjoy it?” I tease.

“How could I not fucking enjoy that? You and Annie…with the tail…” His eyes roll back and he groans, then reaches around and pulls me down on top of him, biting my bottom lip.

“As much as I’d love to do Round Two, I have to go into the shelter for a while. Aileen had a family emergency. I thought maybe you could come with us?”

“It is too early,” Annie groans, stretching her body out and waking Rex, who chirps in annoyance.

“What if…” I murmur, moving over to kiss her collarbone, “I told you that Mama Cat might have had her babies last night?”