Page 53 of Falling for A Lie
“What the hell did I do? She practically sold herself for their protection! She said she couldn't be with us, and that we either had to settle for the occasional hookup and be happy because that was all she could offer us.”I slam my fist against the metal door release, which crashes back and hits the gym's concrete wall. The warm air brushes against my skin as I continue my trek back to my Chevy Chevelle. I click the unlock button on the key fob and the car chirps. I wait for my best friend to respond to what I just told him, hoping to see some sign of emotion.
“It was always her decision; we weren't specific about what we wanted. I also knew she wouldn't be ready to date yet. You assumed that because we had sex, she would be with us. So whose fault is it?”He pulls open the passenger door and climbs into the car, slamming it shut once he's fully seated. He sits there for a moment, the anger and acceptance of the situation crossing his features. “We can't control her body or what she decides to do with it. We aren't her ex; whatever choice she made was one she believed was the right one. We respect her, even if it's hard, even if it hurts because I refuse to let her shut us out. To shut me out. So I'll take what she offers until she changes her mind.”He says this while pulling a cigarette from his pocket along with a lighter. He slides it between his lips and lights it, inhaling the minty nicotine with a soft sigh. He looks out the windshield as we watch the girls exit and enter Soren's car parked right beside mine. “I don't know if I can do it. I don't know if I can watch her with them and be okay, Miles.”My voice comes out broken, reflecting every emotion swirling through me in that moment.I'm pissed.
"We can't force her to choose us, Finny," Mileswhispers through his exhale, the smoke billowing around us in the small cab.
“You're right. We can't,”I grumble, gripping the steering wheel as I watch Soren walk the girls to her car and lift her mask just enough to kiss their exposed faces. She sits there talking, her hand gesturing in our direction, while Scar's boyslounge by the blacked-out Cadillac, their eyes fixed on Soren and the girls as they exchange another quick goodbye. Miles and I remain rooted in place, ensuring the girls are safely inside Soren's car before turning our attention to the woman herself, who is ushered into the back seat with Caden and Radley sliding in right behind her. Reed's cocky smile directed at us makes me wish I could run the arrogant little bastard over without facing the consequences of that choice. Once Reed and Drake enter the car, they waste no time; the vehicle speeds away before we even reach the exit. An unsettling feeling that something is amiss gnaws at me throughout the entire ride home. I must have zoned out while driving because, when we finally arrived, I had no recollection of how we made it in one piece.
I exit the car and make my way into the place I once called home, but it no longer feels that way now that she is not here.Everything else blurs as I dissociate and retreat into myself for the rest of the night. I make my way to Soren’s room to sleep, finding Miles already lying in her bed with her pillow against his chest, his soft snores echoing around us. I sidestep the clothes and shoes that are haphazardly sprawled at the end of her bed on the floor. Once my head hits the pillow, everything fades as I'm pulled into sleep with her scent suffocating me.
Chapter thirty-three
Caden
Soren sits between Radley and me, as quiet as a mouse. Her face is a mask of emotions I can only imagine. Drake and Reed keep glancing at us in the rearview mirror, eager to see how we will proceed. I steal a glance at Radley; his eyes are fixated on Soren's bare thighs, the hunger in his gaze urging me to make the first move on our new plaything.
I place my hand on her thigh, eliciting a soft gasp from her lips as her attention snaps toward me. Her icy blue eyes, glistening with unshed tears, evoke a twisted sense of joy in what I am about to do to her. I gradually inch my hand higher up her thigh, moving toward the center. Towards her soaked pussy.My heart thrums for another taste of what I know is sweet.My eyes watch her eyes before catching sight of her tightening her grip on her phone; a slight tremble from my touch sends waves of pleasure through my veins, straight to my hardening cock. I groan, catching Rad's attention. A smirk graces his lips as he observes my hand for a moment before his patience runs out. He places his hand on mine, pushing it up against her bare skin.The little minx isn't wearing any underwear at the moment.
Her wetness coats my skin as I gradually ease a finger against her folds to the nub, I grip it in between my pointer and thumb and pinch down on it slowly. The movement causes her hips to buck up and a loud yelp echoes from her lips. Rad bites his lip, and brings his hand up, pushing her back into the leather seat. His hand grabs her right tit roughly, rubbing over what I can only assume is a nipple piercing. He continues holding her there as I use my free hand to move her dress to allow the others to see what I'm doing to the girl beside me. I twist the nub one more time before I release it. I rub my thumb over it to ease it slightly, as my pointer pushes into her soakingwet hole.She attempts to squirm, but Rad's grip on her prevents her from getting far.
I glance away from her to check if the other two are watching, only to find their eyes now fixed on Soren. The thought of making the two in the front seat suffer compels me to insert a second finger and gradually begin thrusting, aiming to bring her slight pleasure.
‘Slide by Chase Atlantic’ plays softly in the background, and the sound of her gentle moans blends seamlessly with the atmosphere. I take a chance and slip my third finger into her wet entrance, the walls of her cunt sucking my fingers in, as if trying to hold them captive. As I quicken the pace, I begin to target that sweet spot.
“Fuck. Please, Caden, it's too much.”She says through gritted teeth.
“Oh, well if this is too much, how do you expect to take four cocks?”I give her a bored look as I slow my pace. “Rad, Baby, help me by putting those talents of yours to use. Eat our toy while I continue to show her that she can handle much more than she thinks she can.”
She looks at him, surprise gracing her beautiful face as I watch my man slide down the seat to place his face against her soaked pussy. I feel his tongue licking my fingers as I pull out slowly, the squelching of her juices causing Radley to suck in a deep breath before he begins to feast on her like a starved man. I seize the opportunity to bring my wet fingers up toDrake. “Go ahead and taste what's to come,”I taunt him, watching as his eyes heat up in the rearview mirror. His hands grip the steering wheel as he takes the last turn onto our road, saving us only ten more minutes before we reach home.I slide my wet fingers against his lips, smearing Soren's juices onto them with a wicked grin as he lets out a loud moan before he laps her essence from his mouth.
I fix my gaze back on Radley as he turns Soren around to achieve a better angle, her thighs wrapped around his shoulders and his head nestled between them. The slurping and sucking sounds surround us, and Soren's broken pleas urge me on as I slip my hand down her chest and onto her peaked nipples. I grasp the metal bar of her piercing and twist it, causing her to scream. Her hands grip my forearm tightly as she struggles in vain to escape the sensations we are eliciting from her.“Stay still, or I will set up the cross when we get home and have my way with you like that.” The warning hangs heavily between us as she clenches her jaw.
“Damn. She likes that idea; she just gushed in my mouth when you said that, baby.” Radley groans, his face soaked with evidence. “I can fuck you, while you take her, baby. Drake can enjoy that mouth of hers while Reed sucks on those luscious breasts.” I whisper against her neck as I continue my assault on her pebbled nipples, watching Radley dive back into feast on her, his teeth nipping and pulling at her sensitive skin. Her soft gasps echo throughout the car as Drake turns off theengine and shifts his attention toward us, captivated by the show we are putting on. Reed curses as he reaches back to wipe the tears staining Soren's pale skin, her blue eyes locking onto his as she watches him lick the salty tears from his fingers. His tongue ring glistens in the moonlight, and she loses her battle to remain quiet, shattering at the sight. It seems this beautiful girl will be tied up like a sacrificial lamb tonight. “Oh, beautiful girl. You have no idea what you've just done. Rad, enough; let's get this beauty inside and tied up.” My voice sends shivers down her spine, and mine, making my already hard cock strain against my black denim pants. Radley slurps up her juices and bites down on her thick inner thigh before leaning up to follow my commands. Soren's breath stutters as she is released from both of us, her blue eyes searching for an escape from the devious plans we have for her. She is met with four sets of hungry eyes, and she closes hers, reciting something unintelligible.
“You can't exactly tie me up if we're still in this car, can you? Or was that all just talk, Caden?” she retorts, her hands smoothing the fabric gathered at her hips. She looks at us, a challenge evident in her bright blue eyes as she makes it her mission to stare each of us down, waiting for a response.
“You little brat. Let's go; I'm going to show this little creature what she's been missing.” Reed snaps, opening the passenger door and standing outside, waiting for us to make a move.
Soren chuckles darkly and decides to take matters into her own hands. She crawls over my lap, deliberately showcasing her bare ass as we watch her with unwavering attention. She opens the door and climbs out, standing there with her hands on her hips, waiting to see who will be the next to move and get this long night ahead of us underway. “Well?” She smirks at me before she turns on her heels and stomps towards the front door without another second's pause.
“This fucking woman is going to be the absolute death of me. Mark my words,” Drake groans as he gets out, Reed following closely behind him as they continue their path toward Soren.
I glance over at Radley's stunned expression as he grips himself and groans before following the others inside. “Let the games begin, pretty boy,” he says, his voice laced with desire. “Let's settle the score,” I smirk and step out of the car, shutting the door behind me. As I run to catch up with the others, the weight of the situation hits me. Upon entering the front door, I find Soren standing in the living room, naked, with her hands on her hips, waiting for us to make the next move. The hesitation that once lingered is now absent; and she stands looking like a goddess, bare and willing to do whatever it takes to protect those she loves.
Even if it means surrendering to the devil’s mercy. I stalk forward, pushing past my best friends. As I grip her jaw between my fingers, I lean in and capture her lips with mine.
Every thought eludes me as her tongue slips between my lips, battling mine for dominance. I groan and move my hands from her face down her body to her hips, digging my nails into her soft flesh and pulling her closer to me. I lose myself in her, and the last coherent thought I can muster from my lust-induced state is thatI hope this isn't a mistake.
Chapter thirty-four
Drake
Iwatch as Caden gently caresses Soren's bare body, and I struggle to suppress the urge to join the scene unfolding before me. I have longed for nothing more than to be with her, but I also understand that she does not want a virgin involved in what will undoubtedly happen tonight. So, like a good boy accustomed to following orders, I stand back and observe.
I see Radley approach Soren from behind, slowly wrapping his arms around her waist and lifting her effortlessly. She lets out a breathy moan from the bite Caden left on her lips, which are crimson from the cut his canines have undoubtedly inflicted. I watch Reed hesitate for a moment before he mumbles a quiet ‘Fuck it’ stomping his way toward her just as Radley lays her on the pool table, the deep burgundy felt contrasting with her pale complexion. Caden shoots a mischievous grin in my direction and nudges my brother, a quiet conversation unfolds as Soren is preoccupied with Reed, who kisses her skin with precise licks and nips at her sensitive areas. The act alone causes her breathing to quicken, and she shifts, moans escape from her tempting mouth before I can make my escape to seek some release.
A soft, feminine voice breaks through my psyche “Drake.. why aren't you here?” She looks sad that I'm not taking part or maybe.She probablythinks you don't want her. Way to go, idiot.
Before I have a chance to speak Radley is opening his big mouth and letting the one secret I never wanted her to know out “ He's never fucked anyone before, so he's scared to fuck you and you not enjoy it.”