Page 21

Finding specific numbers on the LGBTQ+ population in New England or any region can be more challenging due to the variability in data collection and reporting. The US Census Bureau and other demographic surveys often don’t directly measure sexual orientation and gender identity across every region with the same granularity as they do racial and ethnic demographics. However, general estimates from various surveys suggest that the LGBTQ+ population in the US accounts for about 4.5 to 5 percent of the population, but this percentage can vary widely depending on the source and methodology.

Sure, for more detailed insights and updates, you could refer to specialized studies or surveys focused on LGBTQ+ demographics, such as those conducted by the Williams Institute at UCLA or local organizations that may have more specific data for New England, but you’re not writing a thesis. You’re trying to figure out what the cast of characters in your New England village should realistically look and sound like.

That said, it’s your village. If you want your demographics to be based on wishful thinking, you go right ahead. Some readers will love it. Some readers will roll their eyes.

Either way, creating a diverse cast of characters in a cozy mystery is important for enhancing the storytelling, enriching the narrative landscape, and reflecting the complexity of the real world.

But let’s keep in mind whatdiversityactually means.

di·ver·si·ty

/d?'v?rs?de, di'v?rs?de/

noun

noun: diversity

1.

the state of being diverse; variety.

“there was considerable diversity in the papers my students handed in”

a range of different things.

plural noun: diversities

“the editorial section displayed a diversity of views from the community”

2.

the practice or quality of including or involving people from a range of different social and ethnic backgrounds and of different genders, sexual orientations, etc.

“equality and diversity create a stronger workforce”

Ideally, diversity in cozy mysteries will reflect realistic, setting-based demographics as well as some calculated choices.

Why is this type of diversity important?

Reflects Real-World Diversity:Our message is stronger and therefore more believable when it reflects reality. Incorporating characters from various backgrounds, cultures, orientations, and experiences makes the story more authentic and reflective of the real world. This realism—versus magical thinking—can make the narrative more relatable and engaging for a wider audience, allowing more readers to see themselves represented in the story.

Enriches the Storytelling:Diversity introduces a range of perspectives, motivations, and interactions, adding depth and complexity to the plot and character dynamics. It allows for a richer exploration of themes and conflicts, moving beyond surface-level narratives to delve into stories that challenge, entertain, and provoke thought.

Expands Audience Reach:A diverse cast can attract a broader readership, appealing to a wide range of people with different backgrounds and experiences. This inclusivity can broaden the book’s appeal, drawing in readers who might not typically explore the cozy mystery genre.

Challenges Stereotypes:By presenting well-rounded, diverse characters, cozy mysteries can challenge and subvert stereotypes, offering more nuanced portrayals that break away from clichés. Not every old person is wise. Not every African American woman votes Democrat. Not every gay man loves musicals. Characters defying stereotypes not only make for more interesting and unpredictable stories but also contribute to a more inclusive and understanding society.

Fosters Empathy and Understanding:Reading about characters who are different from oneself can foster empathy and understanding, promoting a greater appreciation of diversity. When I was in junior high, I read a Scholastic book titledMary Jane. That book, written by Dorothy Sterling in 1971, had a huge influence on me, although I didn’t even remember reading it until quite recently. Cozy mysteries, with their focus on community and connection, provide an ideal setting to explore the lives and experiences of a varied cast, encouraging readers to empathize with and understand perspectives different from their own.

Innovates the Genre:Introducing diversity into cozy mysteries can bring fresh ideas, settings, and themes to the genre, keeping it vibrant and relevant. As societal norms and values evolve, so too should the stories we tell, ensuring that the genre continues to captivate and resonate with contemporary readers.

Builds a Sense of Community:Cozy mysteries often revolve around small communities where everyone knows each other. A diverse cast reinforces the idea that communities are made up of individuals with unique stories, backgrounds, and contributions, emphasizing the strength found in diversity.

Enhances Character Development:Diversity allows for more complex character development as individuals navigate their identities, cultures, and relationships within the story. This can lead to more compelling character arcs and interactions, driving the narrative forward in unexpected ways.

Promotes Inclusivity in Literature:Including a diverse cast of characters contributes to the broader goal of promoting inclusivity in literature, ensuring that diverse voices and stories are heard and valued. This inclusivity enriches the literary landscape, making it more representative of the varied tapestry of human experience.

In summary, a diverse cast in cozy mysteries not only enriches the narrative and broadens its appeal but also plays a crucial role in reflecting and fostering a more inclusive, empathetic, and understanding world.