Page 1

1. What is a Cozy Mystery?

– 1 –

What is a Cozy Mystery?

When We Say Something IsCozy, What Do We Mean?

The term “cozy”conjures up feelings of warmth, comfort, and relaxation. It’s often associated with childhood memories, environments, activities, or objects that make us feel safe, content, and sheltered. Coziness is subjective and can vary greatly from person to person, but there are several key elements that commonly contribute to something being considered “cozy”:

Warmth:Both physical warmth, like being wrapped in a soft blanket on a cold day, and emotional warmth, such as the feeling of being surrounded by loved ones, are essential to coziness.

Comfort:Comfort is key to something being cozy. This can mean physical comfort, like sitting in a plush, comfortable chair, or emotional comfort, provided by a sense of familiarity and security.

Peacefulness:A cozy setting or situation is often quiet and tranquil, offering a respite from the hustle and bustle of daily life. It’s a space where one can relax and unwind without interruption.

Simplicity:Coziness is often found in simplicity and the absence of clutter or chaos. Simple pleasures, such as reading a book by the fire or sipping a warm cup of tea, epitomize coziness.

Sensory Pleasure:Cozy things appeal to our senses in a gentle, soothing way. Soft textures, warm colors, pleasant scents, and soothing sounds all contribute to a cozy atmosphere.

Intimacy:Small, intimate spaces or gatherings can feel cozier than large, open areas or crowds. Coziness often involves close connections with others or personal time spent in solitude.

Nostalgia:Items or activities that evoke fond memories can also be cozy, as they bring a sense of comfort and happiness from the past into the present.

Overall, coziness is about creating a personal haven of contentment and security, where the stresses of the outside world seem far away. It’s a universal desire for warmth and comfort, manifesting in countless ways across different cultures and individual preferences.

Now, WhatExactlyis a Cozy Mystery?

In literature, particularly in cozy mysteries, “cozy” also refers to a genre characterized by crime stories set in close-knit communities, where violence and sex are downplayed or treated with a light touch, and the focus is on the puzzle-solving aspect of the mystery. These stories prioritize the sense of community, the charm of the setting, and the intelligence and intuitiveness of an amateur sleuth, all wrapped up in a comforting, often whimsically detailed narrative.

(Remember that when we’re discussing writing cozy mysteries, we’re almost always talking about writing a series. InA SERIES OF UNFORTUNATE EVENTS, we’ll discuss the elements of successful series writing.)

The roots of the cozy mystery genre can be traced back to the Golden Age of detective fiction, primarily that period between the two World Wars. Authors such as Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Margery Allingham, and Ngaio Marsh were instrumental in shaping the genre. Their works, characterized by elaborate puzzles that emphasized “whodunit and how” over graphic violence or police procedural details, laid the groundwork for what would eventually become cozy mysteries.

Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple series, in particular, is often cited as a prototype for the cozy mystery. Miss Marple, an amateur sleuth solving crimes in her village, embodies many characteristics of cozy protagonists: she’s intelligent, perceptive, a spymaster-grade expert at eliciting valuable intel through gossip and idle chatter, and always operates in a small-community setting, even when in a luxe hotel in the heart of London or a Caribbean resort.

Here’s something to think about: As of this writing, sales in the “traditional” mystery genre are in decline, while the boom in contemporary cozy continues unabated.

While the Golden Age set the stage, the cozy mystery as a distinct genre began to take shape more clearly in the latter half of the 20thcentury. It was during this time that the genre started to be recognized for its unique characteristics: amateur sleuths, minimal violence and sex, and settings in small communities where everyone knows each other.

The 1960s and 1970s saw a rise in mystery novels that focused on character and puzzle over hard-boiled detective work, further paving the way for the cozy mystery genre. However, it wasn’t until the 1980s and 1990s that cozy mysteries began to be marketed and recognized as a distinct subgenre. Publishers started to capitalize on the growing market for mysteries that eschewed graphic content for a gentler, more character-driven narrative.

Today, the cozy mystery genre has expanded to include a wide variety of themes and settings, from culinary cozies to paranormal, hobby-based (knitting, gardening, etc.), and even pet detective series. This diversification reflects the genre’s adaptability and its appeal to readers seeking both comfort and intrigue in their reading material.

The rise of digital publishing and self-publishing has further contributed to the growth and diversification of the genre, allowing more authors to contribute their unique takes and reach audiences directly.

The separation of cozy mysteries from traditional mysteries underscores a shift in some readers’ preferences toward stories that emphasize community, puzzle-solving, and relatable protagonists over the grittier, more procedural aspects of crime solving and puzzles that exist more as mathematical equations than organic revelations of character.

The cozy mystery genre offers readers an escape into a world where justice is served in a manner that’s both satisfying and comforting, a niche that continues to grow and evolve with changing reader tastes.

Tracking the genre’s evolution from the Golden Age of detective fiction to today’s diverse offerings provides insight into not only the genre’s history but also its enduring appeal. Cozy mysteries have carved out a significant place in the mystery genre by offering something unique and beloved by a dedicated readership.

Subtle and Not-So-Subtle Differences Between Cozy and Traditional Mysteries

If you’re familiar with my work, you know that I write both traditional gay mystery (the Adrien English Mysteries, Holmes & Moriarity, etc.) and M/M or gay cozy mysteries (such as Secrets and Scrabble) as well as mainstream cozies. It might be helpful to examine some of the small but significant differences in these two subgenres.

Cozy Mysteries

Setting:Cozy mysteries often take place in small towns or close-knit communities. The setting itself is usually as important as the characters and plot, providing a charming, often idyllic backdrop to the story.