Page 51 of Sinners’ Appetite

The next morning.

Once we’re dressed and ready for the day, we head over to Sammi and Jeremy’s cabin to check in on them and let them know that we’re heading out for a good portion of the morning. After a few knocks, Sammi answers the door, looking like she hasn’t slept for days.

“Good morning.” I greet her, trying not to laugh at the way her hair is knotted all to hell.

“Fuck. Is it morning already?” she sighs.

“We’re heading out on the boat. Probably be back in a few hours.”

“Sounds good. I’m gonna take a shower and try to wake Jeremy up. I had him up quite late…” she smirks, looking back at Jeremy spread out on the bed like he’s passed out drunk.

“Make sure you get some water into him…” I laugh.

“You bet,” she chuckles. “I’ll catch up with you guys later.”

We head down to the wharf and Dean starts to untie the boat from the post. It’s then that I suddenly remember the necklace. Jeremy has Sammi’s with him in their cabin, but I forgot to give Nikki hers.

“Hey, babe… I forgot something back at the cabin. I’ll be right back.” I smile, turning to head back from where we just came from. Once inside the cabin, I grab the velvet box from inside my suitcase and practically run back down to Dean’s boat.

“Close your eyes,” I say, taking a stance behind where Nikki is standing.

Opening the box, I hold the necklace up and unclasp it, bringing it around her neck to secure it. Her hands immediately wander to the vial and she opens her eyes, staring down at the crimson liquid inside.

“W-what is this?” she asks, confused.

“Take a guess… What does it look like to you?”

She twists her mouth at the corner and hesitates to speak for a moment. “A necklace? With… something in it?”

“Yes, but what do you think the something is?”

“Malachi—it looks like blood…”

I smirk and lightly chuckle. “That’s because it is.”

“Please tell me this is your blood?”

Shaking my head, I reach for the vial and hold it between my fingers. “Nope. Guess again…”

Her eyes widen and she lets out a soft gasp. “Paul? Is this P-Paul’s blood?” she stammers.

“Sure is.”

For a second, she almost looks disappointed. Rightfully so. I think I may have jumped to conclusions about how much she would actually appreciate a gift like this.

It’s rather… morbid.

“I don’t know what to say…” she whispers, her eyes locked on the vial.

“You don’t even have to wear it, baby girl. It’s more for keepsake purposes.”

“I mean…thank you?” She finally smiles, relieving the tension in my body a little.

The last thing I want is to scare her, but I also want her to know how serious I am about protecting her. I’d do literally anything for her and I’ll spend the rest of my damn life proving it.

Just then, Dean walks around the boat and takes the necklace into his hand. “I think it looks pretty damn good against your porcelain skin.”

She lets out a huff. “If you say so…” She smiles, taking one last feel of the necklace before she climbs up into the boat.

It doesn’t take long before we’re out in the middle of the lake, veering a little to the left to head down one of the channels that has a giant patch of lilies just before you get to where the fish are plentiful.

Dean never goes this way. In fact—I remember him bitching to me on the phone for a week because he decided to push through them and the plants plugged the propeller on his motor. It took him four hours to paddle his way out of that patch.

“You two need to see this…” Dean says as he points down the channel.

“Are those—lilies?!” Nikki asks in a bubbly, enthusiastic tone.

God—she’s so fucking cute.

I can’t wait to see what she’s like at a zoo.

“They are. It’s the only patch I’ve found around here, but they multiply every year. There’s a ton more than there was last year.”

“Can we get close enough to pick them?”

“I should be able to pull that off, as long as I keep my damn motor away from them.”

Dean then steers the boat forward, headed straight for them. When we get close enough, he shuts off the engine. Only, instead of stopping entirely, we keep heading straight into the center of hundreds of lilies.

“Shit—I won’t be able to start the motor with all of these around.”

Nikki lets out a playful sounding giggle. “I guess we’re just stuck here. All three of us…alone…”

“We’ve turned her into a monster…” I snicker.

Nikki then pulls her phone out of the waterproof bag and starts to take pictures of the scenery, the smile on her face giving me butterflies in my stomach.

“This is just—so damn beautiful…” she peacefully sighs.

I lean in closer to her and reach up to pull the hair away from the side of her neck. “I have an idea, baby girl,” I whisper into her ear, visibly giving her chills.

“I’m trying to take pictures, Malachi,” she whispers in return, lowering her phone to her lap as she tilts her head back against my shoulder.

“Exactly,” I start to say. “Maybe we should take more pictures…of you?”

“I think he’s right. There’s no sense in wasting this beautiful scenery.” Dean groans as he stands up and makes his way over to us, kneeling in front of Nikki.

“I’m a little camera shy, boys.” She whimpers as Dean reaches up to her thighs and spreads her legs apart slowly, biting down on his lower lip while flipping her skirt up.

I grab her phone and get up to sit on the bench seat behind where Dean is kneeling so I can get a better shot. As Dean sinks between her legs, I hit the record button and lean in closer so I can capture every moment up close.

The video captures the look on her face when Dean sucks her clit into his mouth, pulling upward as he shakes his head, making her whimper softly.

Dean lifts his head and looks up at her, sticking his tongue out so she can see her arousal dripping from his tongue. “You get so wet for us, princess,” he groans, diving back down between her legs as she reaches for the back of his head, pressing him into her.

He reaches for her legs, pushing them back further as he sinks his tongue inside her pussy, moaning against her as she lifts her hips.

“That’s my girl,” I whisper, spitting down into the palm of my hand and wrapping it around my shaft. I look around me for a spot to set the phone up and place it where everything is within view, even the lilies in the background.

I sit down beside Nikki and push her forward slightly so I can lift her shirt up over her head, forcing her to free her hand from Dean’s hair. I then lean over, wrapping my mouth around one of her nipples, sucking harder as her moans start to get louder and needier.

Keeping my eyes held on Dean’s mouth devouring her, I reach down and grab his hair, pulling him off her. “I think she needs a cock inside her…” I groan as I replace his tongue with three fingers inside her drenched pussy.

Within seconds, he stands up, placing his hands beneath her ass to lift her hips up and circles his cock around her clit. As soon as I remove my fingers, he slips inside her.

“Nice and slow… don’t let her come yet,” I hiss, bringing my fingers up to her mouth and pushing them past her lips to the back of her throat.

She starts to gag, keeping her mouth wide open as I push harder. The second her eyes roll back, I pull them out and grab the back of her head, forcing her open mouth down onto my cock.

“You fucking love it when I make you choke, don’t you, baby girl?” I seethe through my clenched teeth, sinking inch by inch further down her throat.

After a few seconds of holding her head against my pelvis, I pull her up and smirk when I see the tears streaming down her face.

“So fucking pretty…” I whisper, rubbing my thumb under her eyes.

She dives back down with hunger, sucking my cock into her mouth with so much force that I gently tug up on her hair.

“You’ve got a greedy little mouth, don’t you?” Dean chuckles, watching the two of us closely as he picks up speed with his thrusts, slamming into her hard enough to make the boat start to sway.

Nikki looks up at me, her eyes sparkling in the bright sun. “Come on, Daddy—I’m so…fucking thirsty…” she whines, her voice cracking a little each time her body jolts upward.

Knowing damn well that I’m not far from coming if she keeps this enthusiasm up, I grab the back of her neck and hold it there while I lean in to bite her lower lip.

At the same time, I reach down to her pussy, resting my thumb on her clit as I push three fingers inside her, rubbing along the top of Dean’s cock as he pulls back to watch what I’m doing. When I let go of her lip, she lets out a loud gasp.

“Oh fuuuckkk!” Nikki cries out, her pussy tightening around my fingers.

“Not yet baby…” I demand as I push my pinky finger inside along with my other three fingers, holding them tight around Deans cock and I start to jerk him off inside her.

Dean reaches down, pressing his palm against her lower abdomen as he quickens his thrusts, working his smooth, warm cock deeper and deeper.

Nikki’s body starts to shake, her legs visibly vibrating as she leans forward to look down at herself. A sassy, sly smirk forms on her face, challenging both of us to step it up a notch.

Next thing I know, Dean pulls back, moaning as his cock plops out of Nikki. “Your turn…I think I wanna test that ass out…”

He’s not referring to her ass…is he?