Page 11 of Sinners’ Appetite

“I’m so sorry, Malachi,” I whisper. “I wish I could explain everything, but I’m not ready to re-live that moment.”

“Hey, no pressure. No means no, Nikki,” he assures me, removing his hand from the top of my leg.

I stand up, mortified by my little fit of anxiety. When I motion for the door, he reaches for my hand, stopping me dead in my tracks.

“This doesn’t change how I feel about you. I’ll wait forever if I have to.”

Regardless of how I feel currently, his words melt me.

“Can we just forget that this happened? Sammi will go all mother hen on me if she knows I lost my cool.”

“Your secret is safe with me.”

He lets go of my hand and I walk out, my attention immediately brought to Jeremy and Sammi near the hot tub.

I see Sammi, bent over the edge with Jeremy thrusting into her from behind.

I shake my head and turn back toward Malachi who’s standing there with a devilish smirk on his face as he shuts the door behind him.

“Should we cheer them on?” Malachi teases, walking up behind me.

Suddenly, every nerve ending on my body feels like its on fire. My clit starts to throb all over again and my heartbeat starts to pound through my chest.

“What should we do now?” I ask.

I feel him step closer, his breath hot against the skin on my neck as his chest brushes against my back. “What do you want to do?” he whispers as he brushes his lips against my ear, sending waves of euphoria through my entire body.

I feel my knees getting weaker as I focus in on Sammi and Jeremy. Sammi’s head is lowered, so neither of them even know that Malachi and I are watching them. Not that they would care.

Watching the two of them is somehow encouraging.

I feel Malachi run his fingertips along the inside of my arm, working his way up slowly to my shoulder as he wraps his other hand around my waist. His other hand is resting on my lower abdomen.

Tilting my head back, I let out a soft moan as he slowly slides his fingers under my bikini bottoms, softly growling against my neck when he feels how soaked I am. As he starts to slowly circle my clit, I let out a loud, desperate whimper.

Sammi turns her head toward us slowly, peering out through the strands of hair covering her face. “We have an audience, Jer,” she smirks as she reaches to push the hair out of her face.

Jeremy pulls out, slaps Sammi’s ass and then grips her hips, turning her to face him. He then lifts her up onto the edge of the hot tub and lines up to her pussy, slapping his cock against her clit a few times before thrusting into her again.

The harder he fucks her, the faster Malachi circles my clit. When I can no longer hold back my orgasm, I let go, coming so hard that I completely soak Malachi’s hand. Before I can say a word, he brings his fingers up to my mouth and pushes them past my lips, hooking them behind my bottom teeth.

“I need every inch of my cock inside you…” he breathes into my ear, sending shivers up my spine. “Every…fucking…inch, baby girl.”

Holy shit.

I need him.

“Tell me you want me inside you…”

“Fuck yes…” I manage to hiss after he removes his fingers from my mouth.

I look back as he lowers his shorts and without thinking twice about it, I turn around and drop to my knees, opening my mouth for him.

“Are you sure?” he asks, a concerned look in his eyes.

Is it wrong to move this fast? Am I ruining my chances to fully recover from what’s happened to me?

I’m still in control.

He’s not trying to take that away from me.

Maybe this is exactly what I need to feel alive and free again.

Justin may have tried to destroy me, but he didn’t. I’m still here, and I should be able to live my life however I see fit.

Fuck him.

I nod my head, sticking my tongue out. He reaches for the back of my head with one hand while he lines his cock up to my mouth with the other. As soon as his cock slips past my lips, I wrap my mouth around him, sucking so hard that he taps my head gently.

“Easy, baby girl, you’re gonna make me cum way too early,” he groans.

I allow his cock to pop out of my mouth and start licking around his balls, bringing one of my hands up to jerk him off at the same time.

“Suck them,” he demands.

I obey and suck one of his balls into my mouth, circling my tongue around it before allowing it to slip out of my mouth then moving onto the next one.

“Ahh, fuck yes…” he moans, keeping his eyes held on mine. “So fucking good with that pretty little mouth.”

His words send me over the edge. I grip his cock harder and lift my head to guide it into my mouth. I hum around him as I slowly take him into the back of my throat.

“Right…fucking…there. God dammit, woman.” He growls as he grips my hair and starts to thrust his cock in and out of my mouth.

Letting him take control completely, he pulls out and stands back to look at the saliva dripping from the corners of my mouth. His thumb finds my bottom lip and he pulls it down. “You’re such a good fucking girl. Stand up for me.”

I slowly stand, our eyes locked on each other as I turn around and grind my ass on his cock. He then grabs the string on the side of my bikini bottoms and pulls it so they drop down to my feet.

“I can’t fucking wait to feel you from the inside,” he moans, wrapping his arm around my waist tightly as he slides his cock between my legs, grazing my clit before pushing inside me.

He teases my pussy with just the tip until I slam my ass back into him, causing his cock to thrust inside me. I let out a giggle as he reaches up to wrap his hand around my throat. “Are you being a greedy little slut, baby girl?” he says, pulling me back toward him.

“Fuuuckkk, deeper!” I holler out in desperation.

“As you wish,” he says, thrusting into me so deep that I can no longer stand on my own two feet.

He pulls out and walks me a few feet toward the table that’s even closer to the hot tub, bending me over it before pushing into me again. This time, he goes slow, teasing me at first with just a few inches until I once again push my ass back into him.

I keep my eyes held on Sammi while Jeremy pulls out of her and dips down between her legs, sucking her clit into his mouth as she grabs his hair and holds him there. She opens her mouth but not a single sound escapes her lips.

Malachi runs his hands up my back and when he gets to my shoulders, he grips tight and slams his cock inside me, thrusting into me harder and harder until my pussy starts to painfully ache.

“Oh—fuuuckkk!” I scream before coming so hard that my vision blurs and I collapse onto the table.

Next thing I know, he pulls out again and turns me around, lifting me up by my ass and setting me down onto the wooden table top.

Lining his cock up to my pussy, he slips inside me as his hands grip the front of my legs.

He pushes them back so that my knees are against my chest and holds them steady as he quickens his movements, his eyes focused on his cock penetrating me over and over.

After a few more thrusts, he slows and leans in so his lips are brushing against mine. “Can I come on those tits?” he asks.

“I wanna swallow it,” I say with a wide smile on my face.

He smirks, tilting his head to the side as he lets go of my legs and I sit up, quickly kneeling in front of him, opening my mouth wide for him and closing my eyes, you know—just in case he misses.

“Open those pretty eyes while I cum down your throat,” he demands as he thrusts his cock into my mouth.

As soon as I open my eyes, he grins. “Atta girl.” He growls as he thrusts all the way down my throat, choking me with his cum.

I cough a few times when he pulls out and his cum drips out of my mouth, down onto my breasts. As I sit there smiling up at him, I hear clapping behind him. I move my head so I can see around his legs and spot Sammi and Jeremy applauding us.

“That was fucking hot,” Sammi says with a sly smirk on her face.

Malachi pulls his shorts back up and taps my cheek with his hand. “You did so good, baby girl,” he praises.

Baby girl…

I like that. A lot.

“Why, thank you.” I snicker as I stand and search the ground for my bikini bottoms.

“No problem,” he replies, slapping my ass as I bend to grab my bottoms from the ground.

I slide them back on and tie the string before excusing myself to head inside to the washroom. Sammi follows me in and starts to laugh when we make it inside.

“Damn, girl. Malachi really puts in the effort, doesn’t he?” she says.

I turn toward her. “So, it wasn’t weird that we were watching?” I ask.

“Fuck no. You needed a good fuck and if watching us helped the process, so be it.”

“I panicked in the sauna…” I admit.

“Really? What happened?”

“Things got heated and when he stood in front of me with his cock in his hand, I froze.”

“Did you tell him anything?”

I shake my head. “No. He seemed to catch on right away. That’s why we came out so fast. Then we saw you two and I somehow put all of my fears behind me.”

A warm smile forms on her face. “I’m so fucking proud of you, baby,” she says, leaning in to kiss the top of my forehead.

“I guess I should be thanking you,” I laugh.

“No worries. I’m just glad I could help.”

I still can’t believe I let him take control of me. I wanted him so badly that I just didn’t care. I knew he wouldn’t hurt me and it felt so damn good to finally let go.

It felt good to trust again.