Page 39 of Sinners’ Appetite

I can feel Dean’s rock hard cock against my fingers through the walls of Nikki’s pussy.

Now—that’s a feeling I can’t explain. The way he’s taking his time with her, claiming her asshole with a level of self-control I’m slightly jealous of.

I want to make him fuck her harder, but that’ll just make him come faster, and we can’t have that. He needs to come with my cock buried deep in his ass.

“Such a pretty little slut…” Dean moans, controlling his depth with his hand wrapped around his cock.

I can’t hold back any longer—I need to be inside her too.

“I think my baby girl needs two cocks inside her,” I urge, pulling my fingers out of her drenched pussy.

“Think she can handle it?” Dean lets go of his cock and allows himself to sink into her deeper.

“Can you handle two cocks inside that tight little pussy, baby girl?”

Her head shoots up as her eyes widen in shock. Dean lets out a light chuckle and rapidly rubs his thumb around her clit. When he picks up speed with his thrusts, he leans down and flicks his tongue against one of her nipples. “Don’t worry, I’ll make you come first so you’re nice and wet for us.”

She lets out a gasp, her eyes rolling back as Dean fucks her ass so hard that she slams her hands down to the edge of the couch, gripping so tight that her hands are turning white.

I stand up, catching a glimpse of Sammi squatting against the front of the couch, with Jeremy’s hands wrapped around the back of her head, thrusting his cock into her mouth so deep that I can see it in her throat.

There’s nothing quite like a woman that can deep-throat cock. It’s fucking magical.

Especially for the well gifted men.

We can’t help that our cocks are thick. We just want to fit in too.

I fist my cock, watching the two of them for a few moments before standing behind Dean, running my hands along his ass as he slams his cock into her one more time, the sounds of Sammi choking and gagging behind us syncing with Nikki’s loud whimper.

“Fuuuckkk! Do that again…” she pleads, digging her heels into his lower back.

“Atta fucking girl.” Dean leans back and pulls his cock out of her with a thick strand of come trailing along behind.

As soon as Dean steps back, I place my hands under Nikki’s ass and slide her over so her head is resting against the well padded arm of the couch. I position my cock over her pussy and thrust into her with so much force I feel like I could come right now.

“Oh my god! Fuuuckkk, Malachi!” Nikki screams as I pull back and slam into her again.

I pull out just as I feel her pussy grab around me. “Up, baby girl, I want you to sit on my cock.”

She stands and I lie down where she was, reaching for her as she climbs onto me and grabs my cock, pressing it against her clit before guiding it inside her pussy.

Dean then positions himself behind her, slipping his fingers inside of her, rubbing them along my cock as I wrap my arms around her, keeping her held firm to my chest.

The second I feel his fingers slip out, I feel the tip of his cock barely grazing my balls before he starts to push it inside. I can feel Nikki’s body shaking and her heart thumping against my chest as she takes a deep breath and slowly exhales in a whimper as Dean finally pushes inside her.

“Oh…m-my…god!” she screams into my ear, making me chuckle.

“That’s it…deep breaths, baby girl. I know you can take it.” I reach a hand up to her head and grab a handful of hair, pulling her head up so I can see her face as Dean pushes deeper and deeper.

Between his slick cock gliding against mine and Nikki’s tight walls constricting around me, it’s almost too much to handle. I had no idea it could feel this fucking good.

As we both start to thrust into her slowly, she lets out a low groan, adjusting to us inch by inch.

“Look at you—so fucking beautiful when you’ve got two cocks filling that hole…”

I place my hand around her throat and push her upward so she’s at an angle and keep her held there, depriving her of oxygen long enough to make her body go limp.

Dean starts to pick up speed while I rest my cock in her pussy, appreciating the friction between our cocks every time he thrusts into her.

“Fucking ruin me…” Nikki hisses, clenching her teeth together as she bounces up and down from how hard Dean is fucking her.

I need to pull out before I fucking come. Christ.

I bring my mouth to her ear and nibble on the edge. “I wanna come in Dean’s ass. Can I do that, baby girl?” I whisper.

“Fuuuckkk yes!” she cries, barely able to hold herself together.

I slip out of Nikki’s pussy and pick her up, sliding out from beneath her and step up behind Dean, once again, grabbing the lube to empty the last amount down onto his ass. When I start to rub my cock around the hole, I hear Sammi speak up from the couch behind me.

“Fuck, baby. That’s so fucking hot. You’d do that for me, wouldn’t you?” she moans.

I glance over my shoulder and grin, keeping my eyes locked on Sammi as I push inside Dean, reaching around to circle my hand around the tip of his cock.

Just then, I hear him slap Nikki’s ass so loud that the sharp sound bounces off the walls around us.

“Keep fucking that pussy…” I growl, reaching up to place my hands on both sides of Dean’s neck as I quicken my thrusts, forcing his cock further inside Nikki every time I slam into him.

“I’m gonna fucking come…” Dean hisses, tossing his head back in pleasure.

“Not until I have that ass dripping in my come.”

I thrust harder, feeling Nikki’s legs shake beneath me as Dean starts to moan louder, the force of my cock breaking him. When my orgasm hits the point of no return, I rest deep inside him, letting my orgasm fill him.

Just then, he pushes forward, his ass tightening around my cock as he comes inside Nikki.

“Fuck yeah…” I growl, sliding my hands down Dean’s back slowly as I pull out and stand back.

Dean then pulls out of Nikki, and pushes her legs apart, running his cock through his own come. Just then, Nikki sits up slowly, and looks up at Dean and I with a mischievous grin on her face.

“Well—” she breathes out, barely able to catch a breath. “If you’re not going to let him fuck your ass, Malachi, at least suck him clean.”

Dean smirks. “I agree. Let’s not let any of this go to waste.”

Without thinking twice, I kneel down in front of Dean and dart my tongue out, licking up one side and down the other, moaning at the taste of their mixed arousal on my taste buds.

Once it becomes too much, Dean pulls back and I divert my attention to Nikki’s pussy that’s leaking so much of Deans come that it’s pooling beneath where she’s sitting.

I push her back into the couch, spread her legs wide open and dive down to lap up the rest of their mixture.

When I’m ready to swallow it down my throat, Nikki grabs my head and pulls upward. “Let me see it on your tongue…” she hisses.

I stick my tongue out, lean over her mouth as she holds it open and spit the mixture into her mouth, grabbing hold of the front of her throat. “Swallow for me, baby girl.”

She slowly closes her mouth and swallows, sticking her tongue out after to show me that its all gone.

“Fuck, baby girl. You did so good,” I groan, kissing her lips before standing back up to smack Dean’s bare ass.

“You two are fucking relentless…” she sighs, reaching for her t-shirt on the floor.

“Get used to it, baby girl.” I smirk. “We’re nowhere near done with you yet.”

“I could live inside that pretty little pussy,” Dean groans before he pulls his pants up and walks off toward the bathroom.

A little while later, he comes walking out, motioning for Nikki to come to him. When she gets to the bathroom door and peaks inside, she smiles and lets out the most adorable little squeal.

“You ran a bath for me?”

“It’s the least I could do,” he says, his voice comforting and warm.

I loved the thought of sharing her with him, but—I can’t help but feel like there might be more to it than just sharing the woman I’m madly in love with.

I’d be perfectly fine if it stayed like this.

The three of us.