Page 36 of Sinners’ Appetite

I walk up to Dean, placing my hand on his shoulder as he takes a sip of beer. “Hey. Can we talk?” I ask.

He slowly turns to look at me. “Sure. I’m gonna head up to the cabin to get some more ice.”

I shoot a wink toward Nikki and follow behind him. When we get into the cabin, I can’t think of anything to say.

“I’m sorry, Malachi. I shouldn’t have been so hard on you,” he says, reaching into the fridge to grab a case of soda.

“You told me what I needed to hear. I talked to Nikki. I told her everything.”

“She’s good?”

“Better than I thought she would be.”

“You told her everything?”

“Everything.”

He nods his head, resting the case of pop on the island. “And she just accepted it?”

“Fuck yeah. She wanted to know every little detail.” I grin. “I think it turned her on a little.”

Dean lightly snickers and shakes his head. “She’s fucking perfect for you, Malachi.”

“I know she is. I don’t know how I managed to keep her interested this long.”

“I think I know the answer to that.” He smirks.

We head back outside and just before we get to the beach, the thoughts of letting Dean fuck Nikki come back into play.

“Hey…” I lead off. “When was the last time you got to sink your cock into a nice warm pussy?”

“Fuck, don’t remind me. It’s been way too long. I’m always so fucking busy doing shit around here.”

I smirk and raise my eyebrow as he looks over at me. “What if…”

His eyes widen and he stops dead in his tracks, his mouth opening to say something, but he stops himself.

“I think she’d be game for a little threesome play.”

“Seriously?”

“It can’t hurt to ask. She’s fucking wild, man.”

“No, don’t do that, it might freak her out,” he warns.

“Trust me… judging by the look on her face and what she let me do to her after I told her about us, I don’t think it would freak her out.”

“Fuck…”

“I’ll ask her tonight.” I grin. “Just be warned—she sucks cock like her life depends on it. Kinda like someone else I know…”

“Shut up. That was just a courtesy blow,” he laughs.

When we make it back down to the beach, Nikki walks over and wraps her arms around me. “You two are good now?” she asks.

“Yup.” I smile down at her. “I have to ask you something later.”

“You can ask me now, if you want.”

I kiss the top of her forehead. “I can wait, baby girl.”

“Ask me! You can’t just tell me that you have to ask me something and leave me hanging like that…”

I glance over at Dean and back at Nikki. “Fine. Let’s go up to the cabin. I think I left my phone up there.”

As soon as we get through the door, she starts to laugh. “Your phone is in your damn pocket…”

“I know,” I tease.

“So—are you gonna ask me something?”

A twitch of nervousness hits my stomach. “You know how much I care about you, right?” I start to say.

She nods her head.

“And you know how much I love being inside that perfect pussy of yours…”

“Jesus, Malachi… just ask me already.”

I take a deep breath, exhaling nervously. “Would you be offended if I asked you for a threesome? With Dean?”

She rolls her eyes and lets out a heavy sigh. “How did I know that’s what you had brewing in that kinky brain of yours?”

“So—is that a yes?” I ask, holding back a laugh.

“You really think I could handle that? Your cock alone is a bit much sometimes…”

I pull her closer to me, running my hand down her back as my other hand cups under her chin. “I think you could. Anything’s possible with enough lube.”

“It’s a yes… under one condition.”

“What’s that?”

She smirks, a hopeful look lingering in her eyes. “I get to watch you two fuck.”

“I fucking knew you’d be all over this.” I grin, leaning in to place a gentle kiss on her lips. “Dean was right about you…”

“Oh yeah? What did Dean say about me?”

“He said you’re perfect for me.”

She smiles and buries her face in my chest.

“I think I fucking love you, Nikki,” I blurt out, not thinking twice about the words leaving my mouth.

She moans and looks up at me, tears forming in the corner of her eyes. “I think I love you too…”

I mean every fucking word.

She’s everything I never knew I needed.

Sammi and Nikki have been down at the beach for a few hours now, while the three of us guys tackle an outdoor hot-tub that Nikki insisted we build.

Dean was game on the idea as soon as she said it, so away we went, chopping trees down and thinning them into boards to construct the outside.

He had some left over liner from the pond he built, so we lined the inside with that, and even though it’s completely uneven, it’s quite impressive for three guys that have never built a damn hot-tub before.

“Looks good to me…” Dean says as we all stand back, waiting for it to fill with water.

Finally, the girls come running up from the beach, laughing and giggling about god only knows what. If I could take a guess, it would probably be something to do with what I requested earlier.

Hell—I’d probably invite Sammi and Jeremy to watch. The more the merrier.

Though, I’m not so sure that Jeremy is into that. Seeing my cock buried down another man’s throat might not be his cup of tea.

“You guys did a good job on this!” Nikki exclaims, placing herself between where Dean and I are standing next to each other.

The thought of having her sandwiched between us makes my cock rock hard within seconds.

I walk up to the edge of the hot-tub, trying to think of anything else so that my cock can relax, but it’s no use. The anticipation is far too overwhelming. I can’t wait to watch her suck his cock fucking dry.

“Hey, baby.” I feel Nikki’s arms wrap around the front of me. Next thing I know, her hand is sliding down toward my cock. “Is someone thinking about tonight?” she asks as her hand glides over my hardness.

“Fuck—it’s driving me crazy,” I admit in a low groan.

“I told Sammi, by the way,” she whispers. “Jeremy asked if they could watch…”

I let out a laugh. “I didn’t think he would be into that…”

“Fuck yeah. He’s kinkier than you think.”

“If Dean doesn’t mind an audience, I can’t see why not,” I say, turning around to face her as I adjust my cock up into the hem of my shorts.

“Where are we gonna do this?” she asks with raging curiosity in her eyes.

“I haven’t thought about that.”

“Dean’s living room is nice and spacious,” she suggests.

“You want us to take you in front of that big picture window?”

“Fuck yeah. That sounds hot.”

I grin, placing my hand gently around her throat. “You know what else would be hot?”

“What’s that?”

“If you let me film the whole thing.”

She rolls her eyes. “One step at a time…Daddy.” She giggles.

“Will you two get a fucking room?” Sammi hollers out sarcastically behind us.

“Or at least—turn around so we can watch…” Jeremy chuckles.

I just hope tonight goes as planned. There’s always room for disaster when it comes to threesomes and feelings being thrown around in the mix.

I think it’s fairly obvious to Nikki that I still feel something for Dean, even if it’s not on a “soul-mate” level. The fact that she’s okay with it—is one of the many reasons why I’m falling for her so hard.

How the fuck did I get so lucky?