Page 63 of Find Me

He scoffed. “They’d never make you choose.”

All I could do was gape at him. Was that why he referred to both of them as my boyfriends? Oh goodness, he really thought the three of us were in a relationship together. I began to feel flushed at the thoughts that started filling my head. What was surprising was that I wasn’t turned off by the idea of being with both of them. It was the opposite, actually. “Have they been with the same girl before?”

He took in my red face and gave me a knowing look. “That’s something you should ask them.”

“Do you and Keelan…um, share?” I really didn’t mean to ask that question, but my curiosity got the best of me.

His brows shot up before he gave me a haughty, male smirk. He stepped closer. “Why?” he asked, his tone full of amusement.

“I—” I took a step back.

He stepped forward again. “You’re getting redder by the second.”

“I can’t help it,” I said, taking another step backward, and my back met the front of the fridge.

He closed most of the space between us and flattened his hands on the fridge above my head, trapping me. “Why do you want to know about Keelan and me, Shiloh?”

“I wanted—” Oh, no. Thoughts began to fill my head of the two of them. I couldn’t get any redder, could I?

“Wow, what did I just walk into?” a voice asked. I looked past Knox to see Keelan standing in the kitchen’s entryway off the living room. He was staring at us, a little wide-eyed. “I thought I’d come here and make sure Knox didn’t make things worse.”

Knox glanced at his brother over his shoulder. I took that moment of distraction to escape. I ducked under one of Knox’s arms and booked it to the other side of the kitchen.

Keelan looked from me to Knox. “What’s going on?”

Knox smiled at his brother. “Shiloh asked if you and I share like Colt and Creed do.”

Keelan’s eyes only widened before he gave me the same stupid smirk Knox had given me. “Are you looking to upgrade from Colt and Creed?”

That made Knox snort.

“Cheese and rice,” I cursed, rolling my eyes. “I asked because I was genuinely curious.”

“Just because Colt and Creed like to share doesn’t mean Keelan and I would be into it,” Knox said.

“Speak for yourself,” Keelan said.

Knox looked at his brother, clearly surprised.

“If we both loved the same woman and she loved both of us, would you really make her choose at the risk of tearing us apart?” Keelan asked him.

Knox opened his mouth to respond, then snapped it shut.

Keelan shrugged. “It’s something to consider.”

“I’m not saying it’s wrong, but that type of relationship is kind of unconventional,” I said.

Keelan looked at me. “Times are changing. People are more accepting and polyamorous relationships are more common than you think.”

Knox gaped at Keelan. “You’ve researched this?”

“I did when the twins started dating that girl Emma last year,” Keelan explained. “I was worried about what kind of hardships they’d face by pursuing that type of relationship.”

“Emma?” I said out loud and internally cringed at how jealous I felt.

Keelan smiled at me like he knew exactly what I was feeling. “They dated for six months until she and her family moved to Connecticut. She was…nice.”

“I didn’t like her,” Knox said.