Page 169 of Unspoken Lies

I guess having the decision made for me works best. Jared has always led us, despite the mishaps.

“Mmm,” Elijah says, his nose is shoved into Rachelle’s panties as he smells them, his smirk apparent. “Do you want your pussy eaten out, baby? These panties smell really good.”

“You all make really inappropriate comments and flood my pussy,” she says with a pout.

Her dirty talk has definitely gotten better. The thought of her pussy wet and needy has my cock very interested. Elijah pockets her panties with a grin and stands to kiss her. His hands grab her ass to lift her, and she obediently wraps her legs around his back.

Jared surprises me by grabbing my cock inside my pants and squeezes it. My eyes cross as I grunt, trying to get my hips not to get excited and thrust up.

“You know you miss us,” he growls under his breath. My cock thickens inside his tight fist, and my breath begins to hitch with desire. “Stop punishing us all for shit we’re trying to move on from.”

He’s right. I watch as Elijah climbs onto the bed with Rachelle clinging to him. Theo watches them as he slowly undresses, a smirk playing on his lips.

“Kitten, I’m going to need your lips wrapped around my cock,” he decides, pushing down his pants to expose his pierced cock.

They all seem to work in tandem, while I seem to be the missing cog in their lives. Their eyes keep shooting toward me as if asking what my next move is. Fuck it, it’s a special night. I’ll see how this plays out.

Unbuttoning my shirt a few buttons before pulling it off, I smack Jared’s hand away so I can take my pants off as well. My cock is already beginning to weep with precum and a large drop is sliding down my shaft. Jared’s gaze is laser focused on it as he moves forward and licks up my dick to lap up the drop.

A ragged groan escapes my throat, and I’m suddenly very glad my dad and Julia chose to stay at a hotel tonight. There’s no way that five people would be able to stay quiet enough not to be heard. The door is even open so that Liliana can hear how well we treat our girl.

“He tastes good, doesn’t he?” Rachelle asks with a smirk, letting go of Elijah to twist and crawl closer to us.

“Fucking delicious, wife,” Jared murmurs, kissing her, ensuring that she can taste me too.

My cock jerks upward, making me wince. Fuck, all of this teasing is going to make me fucking feral. I hope the birthday boy is ready to choke on my cock. The way I fuck men is very different than how I fuck Liliana and Rachelle.

I’m softer for them than I am for the guys.

“Querida, I need you,” I purr, loving the way her attention snaps to me immediately.

Jared, Theo, and Elijah watch in awe as I pull her into my arms and kiss her, flopping onto my back.

“Are you ready to take your throne?” I ask her teasingly. “Remember whose tongue is fucking you and making you come.”

“Yes,” she says, blinking as if to brush off the haze of arousal. I have a feeling that we’ll be fucking for most of the night. We’ll watch to make sure she doesn’t drift too far from us.

My hands on her waist, I lift her easily so that she is sitting on my face, her eyes toward my feet. Any and all reminders that it’s me are necessary. Watching Elijah suck my cock will also help her come faster. Every tendril I can use to ground her, I’ll use.

Spreading her ass wide as she sits her cunt over my tongue, I groan as I begin to eat her out. Rachelle sighs as she rocks over my face, her earlier hesitation when we first began doing this completely lost. Her fingers link in mine as I squeeze her thigh and ass with my hand.

“Fuck, you look so pretty and flushed, Kitten,” Theo rumbles, his voice closer than before.

A hand grabs my cock tightly from where it’s bobbing lazily in the air, a hot mouth following quickly after. It’s funny, you’d think after two and a half years, I’d forget what it feels like to get a blow job from one of them, but I haven’t. Elijah’s tight throat is as familiar today as it was in high school.

“Ass up, Baby Boy,” Theo croons. “I’m going to need Jared to take your ass while I fuck Rachelle’s pretty mouth.”

Rachelle and Elijah’s moans make my cock swell in his mouth, and my eyes roll back as I relax into the sensations flooding my senses. His mouth is hot and wet, his throat swallowing around my shaft every time he gags.

I can hear Theo moving to my side, the sounds of his cock brushing against Rachelle’s lips making me gasp. This is my favorite new memory of us all that we’re building. I’m really glad I came up here.

JARED

My fingers are covered with lube as I stretch Elijah’s asshole. Myeyes watch the way he opens for me like a fucking flower begging for the sunlight. He’s a natural bottom and a brat. I love when Rachelle and Elijah team up together to wreak havoc.

I feel like the most powerful person in the world on my knees here, gazing over the people who mean the most to me. Liliana too, because at some point, she crept up the stairs to watch. She’s leaning against the door frame and winks at me as she surveys the bevy of limbs, mouths, and an ass about to be fucked.

Elijah rocks forward on his knees as he groans, his ass moving up to accept my fingers. It’s just a hint of how much I’m going to gag him with Nacio’s cock as I fuck him.