Page 29 of My Ex-Best Men (Ex Marks the Spot #4)

***Anthony***

I felt those words in my chest. I had a feeling she knew it, too, judging by the way her eyes watered.

I stood up and walked over, unable to stay away when I felt like I was about to hand her the keys to the rest of my life.

Leaning down, I kissed her shoulder. “I want you to come as many times as you can. Let yourself go with the men you trust.”

I pulled my chair closer and sat where she’d easily be able to watch me and then, I slowly undressed as Zane and Will took their places.

The room was so still that it seemed like we were all holding our breath as Will slowly pushed into Claire.

She gripped the bedding beneath her and opened her mouth to take Zane deep.

All the while, she kept her eyes on mine.

For four people who’d never done what we were doing, things moved seamlessly.

Will and Zane started slow, giving her a chance to adjust, and then slowly increased their pace as they grew more desperate.

Claire was pinned between them, her tits bouncing under her.

On especially deep thrusts, she’d let out a little whine or a slight gag but when Zane tried to pull back, her hand shot up to stop him. Still, she watched me.

The sounds in the room were pornographic with Claire’s cries growing louder as she came for the second time.

I stood up and shrugged out of my shirt while Will hurtled towards his own release.

Skin slapping skin, he fucked Claire harder and reached under her to play with her clit.

That quickly she came again with a muffled scream.

Her eyes fluttered closed but I growled. “Open those eyes, Claire.”

She did as I said and watched my hands drop to my pants. While I pushed my pants down, Will powered his hips into her and then came with a shout.

“Zane?” I nodded to where Will was pulling out of Claire to collapse on the bed next to her.

Zane didn’t hesitate. He moved to get into place behind her and then thrust deep in one stroke, making her cry out. He gripped her hips tight and drove into her like a man possessed.

I moved closer to the bed and leaned one knee on it so I could grasp Claire’s face and hold it steady.

Her pupils were blown out, her lips were swollen—she’d never been more beautiful.

I ran my thumb over her mouth and she stuck her tongue out to chase it.

“Such a pretty girl. Come again for Zane. Come hard, Claire.”

She sucked my thumb into her mouth and tried her best to keep her eyes on mine but eventually they squeezed shut as she came.

I remembered the way her pussy would clamp down when she came and I knew Zane didn’t have a chance of lasting.

It wasn’t a surprise when he shouted her name and came a few seconds later.

Claire slumped forward on the bed after he pulled out and panted as she came down. “Oh, god.”

I turned her over on her back and pulled her hips to the edge of the bed so her ass was hanging off.

I wanted to watch her face when I sank deep.

She was a feast for my eyes with her nipples pebbled and bright pink and her core open for me.

I stared at the mixture of their come decorating her cunt and groaned.

There had to be something wrong with me because I wanted to photograph it and hang it on every wall of my house. She was so fucking beautiful.

Claire watched me studying her body and flushed. “Should I clean up first?”

I growled and gripped her thighs tight. I ran my fingers over her lower lips and smeared the mess into her pink flesh. “Fuck no.”

Will shifted so he could see what I was looking at and swore. He looked at me and then leaned over and cupped Claire’s face. “That’s fucking sexy, baby. You’re taking us so well.”

I fingered her and then used the cream to coat her ass. I teased her until she was breathing harder and narrowing her eyes at me in a silent command to hurry up and do something. “This will be mine again, Claire. Not tonight, though. Tonight, I want this pussy.”

I lined my cock up at her entrance and pressed my hand down on her lower stomach with my thumb on her clit as I pushed deep. I remembered every moment with Claire and I could see each of them in my head like a movie. I knew exactly where to touch her and how to get the biggest reactions from her.

“Zane, Will. Hold her legs open.” Knowing she liked being watched changed things.

I wanted to push every button she had. I kept my hand on her stomach but moved the other up to lightly wrap around her throat.

Then I rolled my hips and watched her eyes roll.

“That’s right. Flutter that pussy for me. ”

Will and Zane fell into place like we’d been fucking Claire together for decades. They watched her as they spread her open and stroked every part of her that I wasn’t touching. They teased her nipples until they were swollen and each pull earned another flutter around my cock.

She felt better than I’d remembered. Her pussy squeezed my dick and sucked me back in each time I pulled out. Her body welcomed each of my thrusts with a little grunt from her throat. I put more pressure on her lower stomach and watched her eyes widen.

Fucking her harder, watching the way her tits bounced with each thrust, I tipped my head back but kept my eyes on hers.

I wanted to see every single reaction that crossed her face.

It didn’t take long for her to scream my name as her first orgasm hit her hard.

She jerked against our holds and tugged at her own hair when I didn’t let up.

“Anthony! Anthony, I can’t! I can’t come again!” She pawed at my chest but I shook my head as I leaned over her, still thrusting hard.

“You can. You know what I want. Did you ever show Zane and Will what you can do?” I panted just as hard as her as I fucked her like an animal. “Show them.”

She came one more time with a scream and her nails buried in my chest. Her pussy spasmed hard enough to suck my own orgasm out of me before I was ready. I was filling her with my come while her body was shaking and tensing as it forced her own come out, coating my thighs and the bed in her juices.

“Ho-ly fuck.” Zane stared on in awe as he watched her squirt.

I fed the last of my come deep against her cervix and then slowly eased out. We all watched as our combined mess leaked out of her swollen pussy with matching sounds of approval. Claire whimpered and tried to close her legs but we kept them spread.

“Don’t hide. You’re fucking amazing, Claire.” Will leaned over her and kissed her softly. “So beautiful.”

She looked at each of us and bit her lip. “Now what?”

Zane pressed kisses up her ankle. “Now we pass out. For no less than ten hours. But if you get a little handsy before that ten hour mark, I’ll still be available.”

I laughed at the confusion bubbling across her face.

Deciding to cut her some slack, I moved to the middle of the bed and laid on my back before pulling her on top of my chest. Without needing to be invited Will and Zane settled on either side of us.

I’d never slept in the same bed as anyone after Claire so I figured it would take me a while to fall asleep with the guys there, but I was fine with it.

Especially because it was clear that as soon as Claire accepted that we were all staying in bed with her she was over the moon.

She stretched out so she was partially on top of all three of us and was letting out her signature snore within seconds.