Page 69

However, he was going to make sure she really remembered this experience and stretch her a bit.

Win-win.

It wasn’t going to help his dick soften, but he was still going to enjoy it.

“You can’t . . . you can’t do it like this!” she cried.

“Course I can, sweetness,” he countered as Jenner moved into position, pushing his hips out and leaning back so she was closer to the edge of the sofa. Then the other man reached down and drew her bottom cheeks apart.

“Fucking heaven,” Tobias said on a sigh.

Immy let out a squeak. But this was only the start of things. She was going to find that out soon.

He coated two fingers in lube and ran them over her back hole.

“Oh my God,” she exclaimed. “Are we actually doing this? Do you really want to stick your finger in my bottom?”

“We’re really doing this, sweetness,” he replied. “Now, take a deep breath in and let it out slowly. Good girl. Just relax. That’s it. Doesn’t that feel good?”

He had his middle finger deep inside her bottom and she was clenching down around him.

“I don’t know if I’d call it good,” she exclaimed.

“I would. You can let go now,” he told Jenner. “Maybe distract our girl.”

Jenner cupped her face between his hands, kissing her as Tobias moved his finger in and out of her bottom. He cupped her pussy with his free hand, feeling her wetness coating him.

Hmm.

Seemed their girl was protesting a bit too much. She definitely liked having his finger in her bottom.

“Deep breath in again. Now out,” he commanded as he pushed a second finger inside her.

Immy groaned and Jenner ran his hand up and down her back. “Sore, baby?”

“It burns a bit. I’m just so stretched,” she exclaimed.

“You’re doing so well, sweetness,” he told her. He moved his fingers in and out of her bottom as he teased her clit with his finger.

Her breathing grew faster and he could feel her tense. When he slid his fingers free, removing them from her ass and clit, she groaned in protest.

“Shh, baby, you’re all right. Tobias is just getting the plug ready for you.”

“Cupcakes,” she muttered.

So adorable.

He coated the smallest plug in lube, then nodded at Jenner. The other man reached down to part her bottom cheeks and Tobias slid the plug into her bottom. It wasn’t any bigger than his two fingers combined. But he knew she would feel nice and stretched.

And she was going to have to sit there with it in her bottom.

“Such a good girl,” he told her as he sat back to study the plug peeking out of her bottom.

Jenner let her cheeks go.

“Are you going to take it out now?” she asked as Jenner sat up with her, turning her to face Tobias.

“Nope,” Tobias told her as he stood. “You’re going to wear this until either Jenner or I remove it.” Then he left to wash his hands.

What?

Nooo. He had to be joking.

You know he’s not. You’ve read books about the heroine being plugged.

But she never thought that she would be that heroine!

Tobias walked back in with a grin on his face. He was enjoying this! Not cool.

“I want to take it out.”

“Is it hurting you?” he asked.

Drat.

“Well, no.”

“Just as well you didn’t lie,” Jenner told her. “Or tomorrow, you’d be getting another spanking and a bigger plug.”

Yikes.

“Can I get dressed at least?” she asked.

“Hmm.” Tobias tapped his chin. “Nope. I don’t think so.”

“Definitely not,” Jenner added.

“But . . . but what am I going to do? Walk around half-naked with a plug in my bottom?”

“No one said you had to walk,” Jenner told her. “We would gladly carry you. I think I’m going to watch some TV, though.”

“Good plan,” Tobias said. “There’s a game on.”

“A game?” she cried.

“Want a snack?” Jenner asked as he turned the TV on to a college basketball game.

Tobias licked his lips as he stared down at her. “Oh yeah, I’m starving.” But instead of moving toward the kitchen, he kneeled on the floor in front of her.

Then, pushing her thighs further apart, he leaned in and took a long lick of her pussy.

What was he . . . ohhh. This was what he’d meant by having a snack?

Her cheeks grew hot and red, but she didn’t try to push him away. Maybe sitting on Jenner’s lap, half-naked, with a plug in her ass wouldn’t be so bad if she got her pussy eaten. So she settled back to enjoy herself.

Jenner reached up under her sweater to play with her breasts. He raised both of her tops, then freed one breast from her bra cup. Then he lightly played with the nipple as Tobias continued to lick her pussy. He slid two fingers deep inside her.

Wow. That felt so weird with the plug inside her.

She could feel her arousal growing. She was getting close to that edge. A whimper escaped her.

“Are you close, baby?” Jenner asked.

“Yes,” she moaned. “I’m so close. Please. Please.”

Just as she thought she was about to come, Tobias drew back. He slid his fingers free of her, then put them in his mouth to suck them before licking his lips.

She waited for him to drag her onto his lap and fuck her. For him to return his mouth to her pussy. For him to do something.

But all he did was stand and sit next to Jenner.

“Taste good?” Jenner asked.

“So fucking good. You should have a taste.”

“I’ll give her a moment to calm down first,” Jenner said.

“Good plan. That wildcat will probably take your head off if you try and touch her clit right now.”

Were they really talking about her like she wasn’t here?

And, seriously? They were going to give her a chance to calm down?

“Calm down?” she snapped. “No one is calming me down. But somebody better make me come. Right now.”

Jenner lifted her, turning her in his lap. She gasped as the plug moved and her pussy throbbed. Then he grasped hold of her chin, tilting her head back to give her a stern look. “Are you in charge?”

She pouted. “No. But I should be. Because if I was in charge, I would be coming right now.”

“The reason you’re not coming right now is because you’re being punished,” Tobias informed her.

“No pleasure during a punishment,” Jenner added.

“Unicorn poop!”

“And being cute won’t help you either,” Tobias said.

She wasn’t trying to be cute. And she couldn’t even take enjoyment in being called cute. Because she was too busy wondering if she could sneak off to the bathroom and take care of herself.

“Do I get to put clothes on?”

“No, I like you half-naked,” Jenner said. “Besides, makes it easier for when I get hungry.”

They were killing her.

“You can’t say things like that!”

“Strange, because I just did.” Jenner tapped her nose. “You know, I think that she might be so feisty because she’s hungry.”

What?

She wasn’t hungry. What was he talking about?

“I think you’re right. And it will keep that sassy mouth busy.”

Tobias undid his jeans and drew them and his boxers down his legs. Then he took hold of his cock, squeezing the base.

Ohh.

Now she got it.

Jenner slid her around so she was lying back over his lap, on top of the cushion that he’d moved away earlier. That put her head right by Tobias’s cock. She placed a forearm on his thigh as she reached out to lick his cock.

“No play, sweetness. Get it into your mouth. Now.”

She took his cock deep into her mouth, sucking. Maybe she could give him a bit of payback. But then Jenner parted her legs and cupped her mound.

And she knew that her payback was going to be returned to her fivefold.

This really was not fair.

Jenner loved his girl’s pussy.

It was soft and warm and it tasted so fucking sweet. He could spend hours with his mouth on her pussy, eating her out.

But she didn’t get to come after breaking the rules, so as he felt her tense, he drew his fingers out of her pussy.

“Keep sucking,” Tobias told her.

Jenner placed his fingers into his mouth. She tasted so damn good. Then he reached over and twisted his girls hair around his fist, tugging slightly.

“Do what Tobias said. Make him come like the good girl we know you can be.”

He never felt as relaxed and as at ease as he did when he was with the two of them like this, or when she was in Little headspace.

Letting go of her hair, Jenner ran his finger over her ass. It was still pink and warm. He parted her bottom cheeks and she moaned as he pushed lightly on the plug.

So fucking pretty.

“That’s it, sweetness. I’m going to come now. Drink all of me down, don’t miss a drop.” Tobias let out a groan, thrusting up into Immy’s mouth.

He didn’t know why he found that so hot. He actually found sharing her easier and more enjoyable than he’d ever dreamed.

Tobias lifted her off his dick and over onto his lap. Then he was kissing her fiercely.

Jenner released his own dick, pushing his pants and boxers down and off his feet.

Then Tobias drew back from that kiss and turned their girl’s head to Jenner.

“Go suck Jenner’s cock. Do a good job and I might take that plug out of your bottom.

You miss swallowing any of his come and I’m gonna tie you to the bed and feast on you all night without letting you come. ”

A small squeak escaped her and Jenner quickly placed a cushion on the floor before she kneeled on it and took his dick deep into her mouth.

Holy fucking Christ.

That felt amazing.

For a moment, he just let her take charge, doing what she wanted as his eyes rolled to the back of his head. But then he took charge.

“Take me deeper, baby,” he commanded. “Now, swallow. Look at you, eating my dick. You’re doing so well. Just a good fucking girl for us, isn’t she, Tobias?”

“The fucking best.” Tobias moved in behind her, one hand went under her sweater to cup her breast, the other disappeared in her pussy.

Immy’s breath hitched.

“Don’t you stop sucking,” Jenner warned her. “Or you’re going to be in trouble.”

She glanced up at him, her gaze hitting his, her mouth stuffed with his dick. And he winked at her. She smiled around his cock.

That was his girl.

She took him deep. And she sucked him hard. When he came it was with a huge shout that filled the room and a big smile on his face.