Miles: I’ve never chased a woman in my life—until Rowan McDaniel. Normally, women fall over themselves for me. I’m six-foot-four, a top NFL tight end for the Boston Revolutions, and I’ve got the charm to match. But Rowan? She loves my sense of humor but is immune to everything else. And I kind of love it.

She’s smart, sweet, and completely out of my league. But when I hear she’s joined a dating app, I decide it’s my shot to prove she’s as into me as I am into her. Game on.

Rowan: I’m the “good girl”—the caretaker, the reliable friend, the...

Miles: I’ve never chased a woman in my life—until Rowan McDaniel. Normally, women fall over themselves for me. I’m six-foot-four, a top NFL tight end for the Boston Revolutions, and I’ve got the charm to match. But Rowan? She loves my sense of humor but is immune to everything else. And I kind of love it.

She’s smart, sweet, and completely out of my league. But when I hear she’s joined a dating app, I decide it’s my shot to prove she’s as into me as I am into her. Game on.

Rowan: I’m the “good girl”—the caretaker, the reliable friend, the nurse who never takes a day off. So, when my coworker tells me about a new dating app, I think, why not? But I didn’t expect to click so fast with a guy who gets me like no one else. I find myself telling him my innermost secrets. Intimate fantasies Ive never shared with anyone else.

The catch? I’m falling for two men—Miles, the football star who only sees my “good girl” side, and the mystery guy I’m spilling my secrets to online.

What’s a girl to do when both worlds are pulling at her heart?