Page 57 of Whisper Pretty Lies (Lust & Liars #1)

Damon

Evan sits at my desk with her feet tucked up on the edge of my chair. The lacy edge of her new panties shows a little, but I’m sure she’s unaware of it. She’s eating the food I asked for from the cook. Her large, blue-gray eyes watch me.

I have my textbook open on my lap, reading a chapter for class. The plug sits on my bed, waiting.

All that’s left is for Hawk and Cam to get here. We agreed at hockey practice to do this together. After all, we haven’t played like this before. I have constant access to Evan, but I don’t want to monopolize her.

It was hot watching them go down on her and suck her breasts as she took my cock. I’m not possessive of girls. That’s not fucking healthy. I fuck them, and if they go fuck someone else, that’s their prerogative. I’m not about to go caveman on a high school girl. Fuck that.

I’ve managed to stay a free agent, even though Olivia seems possessive of me. She’s in a few of my classes and sat near me at the beginning of school. I don’t trust her. I don’t have to trust a girl to fuck her, but there’s something about Olivia that’s just fucking off.

Which means I’m not going there. Not that I can with our deal with Evan.

I’d rather have full access to Evan than fuck around anyway.

Cam texts me that they’re both here. I go to my door and open it, waiting for them to come up the back way. Evan takes a drink of water while she watches me.

It’s taking everything I have not to fuck that pussy. She’s ripe for the taking and so fucking ready, but she’s holding back. She could be testing us. Every time I ask, she says no. What would she do if I took it anyway?

This deal between us means she needs to trust us. If I take her, she wouldn’t trust me. Like today at the restaurant, thinking it was a trap. She needs to trust me not to do stupid shit to blow her up.

Honestly, going to the restaurant at lunch today could have been a move to out the good girl. It’s one I’ll keep in my back pocket. But I’m not done enjoying my blackmail yet. I want her to forget where we are so she goes down on me. Not force her to.

I’ve given her all the promises I can. I’ll fuck only her. But fuck, she needs to let me fuck her properly. I shouldn’t have agreed to her deciding when we get to fuck her.

She takes a bite as she continues to contemplate me.

Of course, taking her out today was jabbing a knife into Chase’s back. He needs to know I’m all over his girl. Maybe he’ll believe her pretty lies.

“Hey,” Hawk says as he and Cam walk down the hall and into my room. “Hey, Annie.”

Cam smirks as I lock the door. “Show me your panties, goody.”

She drops her fork and stands to lift my shirt to show off those lacy panties I bought for her. They’re still fucking innocent looking, but hotter than the cotton ones she had. The cotton ones were utilitarian.

“Good choice.” He bumps his knuckles against my arm.

“Are you done eating?” I ask, and sit on the edge of the bed.

Her eyes widen. “Yes. May I go brush my teeth?”

“We’re not animals, Annie.” Hawk chuckles.

She still hesitates and looks to me. I nod slightly and she hurries into the bathroom. She doesn’t close the door. Good. She’s learning how this is going to go moving forward. No barriers between us.

“We need to figure out how to spend more time with Evan.” Cam sits on the other side of me and picks up the plug with a smirk. “Who’s going to do the honors?”

The water shuts off and Evan stands in the doorway, watching us. I meet her gaze but talk to the others.

“She needs someone to suck on while the other two take care of her pussy and ass.” I love that I get to be blunt with her, though I don’t sugarcoat anything for other girls either. Some girls get mad with that kind of talk, but not Evan.

She doesn’t drop her gaze from mine, waiting for me to tell her what to do. I love that she gives me this.

“Hawk.” I gesture to the bed. “She can suck your cock until you come. Then Cam can go next.”

Hawk undoes his belt and kicks off his shoes.

“Come here, little devil.”

She crosses the floor to stand at my feet. I lean back with my hands propping me up on the bed. My cock is already rising to attention, and her gaze drops to my pants. Yes, girls generally do what I tell them to, but having Evan obey me fills me with lust and power.

“Take off the shirt.”

Her gaze jerks up to mine, but there’s not defiance there. She takes the hem and lifts the shirt off over her head. This is what she’s giving us. The trust we won’t take it too far, that the rules we’ve set in place will hold.

Her arms drop to her sides. Her blond hair is almost dry and falls around her shoulders in soft waves. Cam reaches for her breast, cupping it.

“I can’t wait to suck on these all night long.” Cam leans in and kisses her nipple.

Evan sucks in a breath and presses her thighs together. Her stormy eyes stay on mine.

“Lose the rest, Evan.” My words are a command.

She slips her thumbs in the sides of her panties and lowers them down. Hawk steps up behind her and slides his hand down her stomach.

“You’re going to ride my face after that plug is in your ass, baby girl. I need the taste of you on my lips to sleep tonight.” His fingers slide between her legs and she releases a little moan. “So fucking wet for me.”

He draws his hand back and sucks on his fingers.

Cam and I stand with Evan between the three of us. We’re all taller and larger than she is. Honestly, we’re bigger than most girls and Evan is not particularly tall. She shivers slightly. Naked in a pack of devils.

“Hawk, lie on the bed. This might take some adjusting once we get Evan in position.”

Her eyes widen and I slide my hand over her jaw.

“Don’t worry, little devil. We’ll get it right.” I lift my gaze to Hawk’s. “I want her kneeling on the edge of the bed, ass up with her mouth on your cock. Legs spread open.”

She gasps a little. I stroke my thumb over her bottom lip. These fucking lips. I’ve never been obsessed with a girl’s mouth before, but I want these lips on mine.

“We’re going to fuck your pussy with our fingers and tongues only.”

Her eyes darken with desire. I’d be more than willing to fuck her pussy with my cock.

“Unless...”

“No.” The word is soft, but firm.

“Hmm.” I glance at Hawk as he settles on the bed. “You know how I want you.”

She takes a deep breath and moves to the bed, kneeling between Hawk’s knees. She takes hold of his cock and meets Hawk’s eyes.

“Make me come, baby girl.”

Evan bends over to take him into her mouth. She’s gotten better at blow jobs, at least. She’s downright enthusiastic.

“Suck and lick, little devil, that’s it.” I pick up the lube and offer it to Cam.

He grins and takes it.

“Prep first.” I put my hands on her thighs and spread them a little wider, opening that glistening pussy for me. “Let’s get her ready to take it. We took a shower, and I made sure she’s clean.”

She whimpers. I rubbed her asshole with the soap, teasing her until her breathing hitched, but I didn’t let her come again.

Cam smirks and squeezes her ass cheeks, pushing them together and spreading them open, revealing her puckered hole.

“Such a pretty little hole.” Cam spreads her ass cheeks and bends to lick her asshole. “I’m surprised no one’s fucked it before.”

She moans around Hawk’s cock.

“Maybe she was saving it for us.” Cam slides his tongue against her hole before pressing the tip of his tongue in.

She makes a startled noise.

“Lift her,” I tell Hawk. When he does, I ask, “No one’s played with this ass before us, little devil?”

“No.” The word is breathy as Cam continues to explore her ass with his tongue.

I slide my fingers against her clit. “Has no one tried, or were you worried?”

Her hips rock against my fingers. “No one tried.”

“Chase must have been a lousy lay.” Hawk rubs his thumb against her lips. “Basic fucker. Don’t worry, baby girl, we’ll make that ass feel real good.”

He lowers her back down on his cock. Cam begins to really work her ass with his tongue and she makes these little noises like she’s getting close. I kneel below Cam and slide my finger into Evan’s pussy, before leaning in and sucking on her clit.

She moans hard as I fuck her pussy with my finger and suck on her clit while Cam’s tongue fucks her asshole. She comes all over my tongue as her hips rock against us.

“She definitely likes her ass played with.” Hawk groans. “That’s it, baby girl, suck that cock. Such a good girl.”

Cam straightens and wipes his mouth on his t-shirt before grabbing the bottle of lube and spreading it on his fingers. I lift my mouth from her to watch. My finger circles her clit while I fuck my finger in and out of her pussy.

Fuck, this girl gets under my skin. I want to take out my cock and sink it deep inside her and keep it there while we fall asleep. Having her mouth on my cock while I slept was amazing, but being buried deep in her, with her naked body draped over mine, is going to be even better.

Cam slicks the lube over her puckered hole before sliding the tip of his finger inside. She moans.

“Easy, goody. Relax and let me in. I need to get you nice and slick for the plug.” Cam rubs her ass cheek.

I slow my finger to gently fuck in and out of her pussy until I feel her relax around me. I give Cam a nod, and he slides in a little deeper before coming all the way out and sinking in a little farther. He works his way into her ass until his finger is buried to his knuckle.

She moans softly as I curl my finger to stroke that spot at the front of her cunt.

“Fuck her mouth, Hawk.” I meet his eyes and he smirks as he gathers her hair into his hand. I don’t want to tell Evan what we’re doing, but we’re going to give her a taste of how it will feel to take all of us.

Cam and I alternate fucking in her holes and pulling out in rhythm with Hawk fucking her mouth. She trembles between us. I can feel the press of Cam’s finger through the thin membrane separating us.

“Can you imagine when this is our cocks, little devil? Sliding in and out, filling your cunt and ass with our thick cocks?”

She moans as she comes all over my fingers again. Fuck, I want to feel that pussy clamp down on my cock.

“So fucking tight,” Cam says. “Relax, goody, so I can pull out.”

Hawk groans and Evan swallows him down between panting. “Trade me, Cam.”

“Fuck off.” Cam’s lubing up the toy.

“You don’t want your dick sucked?” Hawk arches an eyebrow, but he hasn’t taken his cock out of Evan’s mouth.

I chuckle. “Put the toy in her ass, Cam, then Hawk can fuck her with it while she sucks you.”

Evan whimpers, but still sucks on Hawk’s softening cock.

Cam presses the tip against her asshole and pushes in steadily. Evan groans and I fuck her with my finger while teasing her clit.

“Relax, baby girl, you’re doing so good taking that plug for us. We’ll be fucking that ass in no time. Then we won’t have to fight over this pretty mouth.” Hawk arches an eyebrow at Cam.

Evan takes little hitching breaths between sucks.

“Almost there.” Cam thrusts in the widest part and she shatters again, clamping down around my finger and the toy.

I stroke her through it and then pull my finger out. “Need to cum, little devil. I’m going to do what we did yesterday.”

She whimpers as Hawk slides out from under her. Her head rests on the bed. He walks around to watch.

I pull my cock out of my sweats and place the tip against her entrance. It would be so easy to slip in, to say it was an accident and fuck her properly, but... fucking trust.

I stroke my cock pressed firmly against her opening.

My fist wrapped around the tip to keep her from taking me as her hips want to rock.

Her entrance kisses my tip like a wet mouth.

She’s a little out of it, so I hold her hip.

We have an agreement. As long as she doesn’t hold out forever, I’m willing to wait to sink my cock into her cunt if it means she’ll trust us.

Hawk grabs the base of the plug and twists it in her ass. She groans and buries her face in my blankets. Her hands grip the fabric tight. Fuck. She’s so sexy when she’s drowning in lust.

Groaning, I press my cock against her as my release shoots out of me. She eases back a little to take me in just slightly. My hand trembles with the urge to pull her onto my cock.

“Fuck, little devil.” I release my cock and slide my finger in my warm cum to bury it deeper inside her. Her cunt pulses around my finger.

“Fuck, man.” Hawk runs his hand down her thigh that’s shaking like a leaf after her orgasm.

“She needs a breather.” Cam slides his hand over her hip while he strokes his cock. “Turn her over and I’ll fuck those tits instead of her mouth.”

I step back and let the others take over. I run my hand through my hair, uncaring that the mix of my cum and hers is still on it. I’m going to need her to give in sooner rather than later. She wants it. I know it. She knows it.

They flip her onto her back and Cam straddles her waist. When he drizzles lube on her breasts, she gasps at the chill. Cam chuckles as he rubs it between her breasts. Hawk tugs on the plug and she lets out a little huff.

I straighten my sweats and lie down next to her on the bed.

“Can you feel me warm inside you, little devil?”

“Yes.” She rolls her head toward me and those stormy blue eyes meet mine. I brush her blond hair off her flushed face, behind her ear. When I rub my thumb over her swollen lips, she parts them.

She moans, but I don’t look to see what the others are doing to that hot little body.

Hawk is either fucking her with his finger or mouth or maybe both while playing with the plug in her ass.

Cam has her tits pressed around his cock as he shuttles it between them, rubbing her nipples as he strokes himself.

But right now, her eyes are on me. They’re blue with streaks of gray through them. Almost silver. I don’t know how I ever thought they were dull. I move in and press my forehead against hers.

“Do you feel how much we want you, little devil?” I say it softly. “This isn’t for anyone else’s benefit except ours. Yours and ours. Your body belongs to us as soon as you’re ready.”

She cries out as she comes and I surge forward to capture the sound in my mouth. She moans as our tongues collide. I slide my hand into her hair and hold her while I explore every inch of her mouth, learning her.

I plan on keeping Evan as my pet for a while. Which means I have to make sure her mother doesn’t go anywhere until I’m ready to be done.