Page 20 of Such A Dirty Girl (Hot Creeps #6)

TWENTY

SARAH

J ake’s gaze burned into me as I sucked on Drew’s fingers. It was salacious and filthy being naked in Eloise’s house, not tucked up in Jake’s room, but for anyone to walk in on.

The scent of old leather and manly musk filled my nostrils. I was painfully aware of the cold wood beneath me, digging into my knees. Still, I didn’t move. Didn’t dare.

What would Jake and Drew do if I did?

They wouldn’t force me to stay. I knew them both well enough to know they weren’t like that. The power games needed to be consensual. But would they come after me? Or would Drew finally get what he wanted? Jake all to himself.

Candlelight flickered over the spines of dusty books and caressed the legs of the two men who had me on my knees. Sweat gathered along my spine as nerves twisted my gut.

Drew’s presence dominated the room. He stood before us, arms folded in a pose that commanded the space. His eyes shone with a cruel satisfaction that made me want to claw his face and worship him all at once.

‘Take your dick out, Jake.’ Drew looked past me, at him. ‘You’re going to learn how to use her mouth properly.’

A zip lowered somewhere behind me. A ragged breath. Drew’s pupils flared as he drank in the sight of my boyfriend’s cock.

Drew turned me around and pushed me forward until my lips brushed against Jake’s cock. Already it bobbed thick and heavy, engorged until it strained. I looked up at him. My Jake .

Our eyes locked, and his breath shook.

‘Open up, Princess,’ Drew ordered, his words hot against my neck.

I didn’t hesitate. Stretching my lips open until they ached, I knelt there waiting to be filled.

‘Tell him you want it,’ Drew teased. ‘Beg for it.’

‘Please.’ The word was sticky in my throat. But I wanted Jake to use me so badly. Craved the degradation of being between them both. ‘Please fuck my mouth. I’ll be so good. I promise.’

I hated the whine in my voice.

Drew pressed me forward when Jake nodded.

Jake groaned as I took him into my mouth, inch by delicious inch while Drew wrapped my hair around his fist, controlling my every move.

His cock was thick, hot and familiar. But taking it felt different under Drew’s watchful eye.

Yes, he’d been beneath the bed the last time I’d swallowed Jake down, but being guided by his deft hand had me squirming.

It was no longer just me loving my boyfriend. We were both performing for Drew. I blazed with the need to show him how well I could worship a cock. Jake’s cock.

Drew’s cock . The thought gripped me, filthy and wrong. Yet, undeniably addictive.

‘That’s it,’ Drew whispered. ‘Take more. I know you’re a greedy little thing. Look at her, Jake. Look how desperate your sweet little girlfriend is to swallow you down.’

Jake whimpered as his hips jerked. I dug my nails into my thighs to keep my rhythm steady as Drew’s grip tightened in my hair. He pushed me down harder, rougher, until spit slicked my chin and tears burned my eyes.

‘Beautiful,’ Drew praised. ‘And so fucking slutty. Drooling all over him like you were made for this. And you love it, don’t you?’

I moaned around Jake’s cock, the vibration making his balls tighten. My cunt clenched, shame mingling with desire.

‘Good girl,’ Drew crooned again, softer, almost tender. His fingers slid behind me, slipping through my wetness. ‘It’s okay to want this. It’s okay to enjoy being used.’

Jake’s fingers grazed my cheek. ‘It’s okay, baby. I love seeing you like this. I love that you’re finally happy.’

My heart cracked.

How could he say that when I was on my knees choking on his dick under his stepbrother’s command?

But I believed him. He looked down at me with adoration before his gaze slipped to Drew, growing more hungry as I continued to please him.

Drew stood, undoing his jeans and dragging them down slowly. My eyes widened at the trail of dark hair leading down to his cock. A happy trail for us to follow. To get lost upon. His dick was thicker than Jake’s, if not quite as long. It jutted out from his crotch, flushed and obscene.

‘My turn,’ Drew demanded. ‘Open wider, princess.’

I whimpered as I switched, eagerly licking up his heavy length before encasing him in my lips. My tongue flattened under the weight of him as he slid into my throat without hesitation. The moan he gave made my core melt. His cock stretched my lips, filling me until I gagged.

Shame burned hot on my face. But beneath it lay desire.

‘Fuck,’ Drew groaned, threading his fingers through my hair. ‘She looks so fucking pretty choking on me, doesn’t she, Jake?’

‘Yeah… God, yeah.’ The way his voice cracked had me doubting myself.

Drew’s eyes glittered, cruel and knowing. ‘But you’re jealous, aren’t you? Because you’re like her.’

Jake froze. ‘I’m not?—’

‘Yes, you are. You’re hard as fuck watching her submit because you want to submit too.’ Drew’s voice was cutting as he interrupted. ‘Admit it.’

The silence was brutal. But I couldn’t see Jake to read his expression. Not with his stepbrother halfway down my throat.

‘Yes,’ Jake whispered.

The word had me sweating. The world lurched, but there was nowhere to go.

Drew held me tight, arching his hips to fuck my face as he made my boyfriend admit to dark desires I hadn’t known he was hiding.

Jake wanted the same thing I did. It was no wonder we’d struggled to be compatible in the bedroom.

‘Then strip,’ Drew demanded. ‘And join Sarah on the floor. At my feet. Where you belong.’

Jake obeyed. His fingers trembling as he pulled his shirt off, baring his chest. Then his jeans. Then everything, until he was naked beside me. I stared at Jake, trying to convey with my eyes what my mouth couldn’t.

My thighs squeezed together as Drew’s smirk widened. His cock casually pistoning my face like there wasn’t a seismic shift happening in our relationship.

Jake bowed his head. My safe place no longer looked steady. No, he looked starved. Like he was waiting to be fed something he’d never dared ask for.

‘Eyes on me,’ Drew said, fingers pushing into my hair and dragging my head back to look at him. He smirked as his eyes slid to Jake. ‘And you. Both of you, exactly where you belong. At last.’

Heat fluttered in my stomach.

Belong?

I shouldn’t like the word. Shouldn’t want this. But seeing Jake on his knees next to me, fuck, it was hotter than anything I’d ever imagined. Disconcerting and nerve-wracking, but hot as all hell.

‘Share me.’ Drew looked from Jake’s face to mine, withdrawing his cock from my lips. It pained me to let it go. ‘Show each other how much you love it. Show me who wants it the most .’

I kissed Jake around Drew’s cock, lips sliding over his engorged tip as we both licked and sucked in tandem. Jake groaned and pressed his forehead to mine, his eyes full of love even as spit and precum coated our mouths.

‘I love you,’ I whispered to him when Drew forced his dick into Jake’s mouth with a groan. ‘I love you. Everything makes sense now.’

Jake panted when Drew withdrew from his mouth after half a dozen ragged thrusts.

‘I love you too,’ he said, before having his mouth filled once more.

Drew groaned above us, thrusting between our mouths, hand tightening in my hair, the other gripping Jake’s jaw.

‘Fuck. This is it. This is what we’ve been missing. Years wasted hating her, Jake, when we could’ve been fucking her together. When we could’ve had this.’

Drew yanked me back by my hair. He pulled me onto his lap on the Chesterfield sofa and spread me wide. His cock pressed against my dripping cunt as he watched Jake kneeling behind me.

‘Your girl feels so fucking good,’ he growled as he slid his fat cock inside me. I glanced over my shoulder to see Jake, right as Drew pressed my hips down, enveloping himself inside of me with a lusty moan.

And with the stretch of Drew’s huge dick, and the absolute look of longing on Jake’s face, the truth hit like lightning.

I didn’t know whether I loved or hated it.

But I knew I didn’t want them to stop.