Page 115 of Creatures Like Us

I pin him with my gaze. “Don’t you remember what I said? I wanted to hear you.”

“That?…” His breath comes out in a rush. “Fuck, that really hurt, Ash. It burned.”

“It’s beautiful though.” I pull at the base of his pec, and the jewelry tingles in the light. “Ready for the other one?” I don’t know ifI’mready, but Noah nods, teeth gritted in determination.

Now that I know what to expect, the process is smoother for the other nipple. Seems like Noah’s adrenaline can’t dampen the second rush of pain as well as it did the first; he grimaces and whimpers beautifully as I slip the jewelry inside.

“How was that, baby?” I ask.

“Intense,” he mumbles. “Hot.”

“Yeah?” I slide a hand down between our bodies to grab his cock, finding it already hard and leaking. “Oh, youreallyliked it. Want me to pierce you here next?” I dig my thumb into the sensitive skin under his crown.

Noah arches his back, lashes fluttering. “Oh?…?Okay.”

I flick my gaze up. “It was a joke.”

“I’d let you though. You know that.”

“Yeah, I know that. Now be still.” I take my gloves off and spit into my palm, working him over with my slick hand. At the same time, I reach behind myself, pushing two fingers into my hole that I already prepped and lubed before we started this, since I figured he needed some pleasure to counteract the pain.

Without further ado, I guide Noah’s cock inside, expression strained as I work myself down inch by inch. Fuck?…?We’ve done this dozens of times by now, but I still haven’t quite gotten used to the intense feeling of his shaft stretching me wide.

“Oh my god, Ash?…” Noah moans.

A whine builds in my throat in reply, but I pull it back, steadying my voice. “Want to do it to me? Pierce me here?” I pinch one of my nipples.

“Would you let me?” With his hands restrained, Noah uses the lower part of his body to rock up inside me, and this time, I can’t hold back the whine.

Fuck, I’m supposed to be dominating him, but maybe it was a bad idea to have him fuck me. I have a hard time bottoming without breaking character.

I brace my hands on his shoulders, gasping as he slams his full length inside. “I-I don’t know. Maybe if I get to fuck you at the same time.”

“Would that work?”

“We could try.”

Noah smiles and shakes his head. “I think I’d get too distracted.”

That’s fair. I never could have focused enough to pierce his nipples if I was riding him like this, especially not now that I’m trying to make him come. I pick up the pace, bouncing my ass onto his cock, impaling myself, and I watch his expression tighten with lust and his eyes widen.

“Fuck, Ash, stop.”

“It’s okay. I want you to come.” I lean down to grab his throat, pressing down on it while I ride him hard. “Doesn’t it feel good? That pain.” I squeeze around his newly pierced nipples, and he cries out as he bucks up inside me, flooding me with his cum. Unable to hold back anymore, I squeeze my ass around his softening cock while I jerk off frantically and come all over his chest.

All over his nipples.

Okay, maybe that wasn’t the best idea.

“Fuck. Sorry.”

“For what?” Noah asks, sweaty and blissfully fucked out.

“I don’t think you’re supposed to treat fresh piercings with cum.”

He glances down at his chest and shrugs. “Let’s take a bath, then.”

“I don’t think you’re supposed to do that either. Here.” I unlock his wrists and wipe him down with a paper towel, careful not to bump his piercings more than necessary.