Page 23

F aye

The guys go along with Maverick’s idea instantly, shirking their clothes and leaving them stranded on the rocks, while I stand completely still, processing what’s happening.

Up until these men, I’d never been naked in front of anyone but my family.

Somehow, just stripping down here feels a lot different than being naked in my bed together.

“What’s wrong?” Maverick asks, appearing in front of me, completely naked.

It’s hard to explain what I’m feeling. While I’m comfortable with him—and all of them—it feels like a lot, all at once, to be seeing them all without their clothes and dripping wet.

It’s like my system can’t handle all the input.

I can’t handle the idea of them naked, or that I’ll be getting naked with them.

“Nothing,” I squeak, and his eyes dart over me, assessing me.

“You don’t want to skinny dip?” He sounds a little disappointed, but not upset.

I can see the other guys watching us, and I swallow, meeting their eyes. The alphas come closer to me. Eli hangs back, watching, and it takes work not to let my eyes drift down to below their hips, where I know there’s too much to take in at once.

“No—yes, I mean?—”

“Maybe Faye just needs some help getting out of her dress?” Ezra says, his hot breath blowing out over the back of my neck as he steps closer.

I suck in a breath, feeling my nipples go tight. That’s not what I wanted, but it might be what I need if I have any hope of getting undressed in front of them.

“Is that okay, Faye?” Xander asks, his hand skating up my arm, sending shivers down to my wrist.

Unable to talk, I just nod, more shivers following the others as Xander slides one strap down my left shoulder, while Ezra unties my dress at the back and Maverick slides the other strap down.

The sensations are so whisper-light, and yet, somehow, they have my core melting with a liquid kind of heat. To have them touching me all at once, the tension in the air building palpably, feeling the want radiating from their bodies, bathing me in admiration and need… it’s incredible.

Then, out of nowhere, a huge wave of water splashes over all of us. I gasp, completely drenched, and Cayson emerges from a nearby hot spring, pushing his hair out of his face and laughing.

“Whoops,” he says, clearly not sorry at all.

Distracted, the guys turn away from me, chasing after Cayson as he desperately tries to swim away from them and their attempts to splash him back. I watch them, my chest warming with affection for them all, when I feel a presence next to me.

“These boys struggle to finish what they’ve started, don’t they?” Eli says, his voice dangerously low.

His fingers land on my skin, and my entire body re-ignites with need. Slowly, he slips my sodden dress off, letting it fall to the rocks below. Then, with the world’s most certain fingers, he takes off my bra and underwear, dropping them in the pile with my dress.

When he takes my hand, I follow him back to a different pool of water. He pulls me in and settles me on his lap. The others must smell my arousal stronger, now, because they all seem to turn at the same time, abandoning their splashing and joining Eli and me in our pool.

“So, we got you naked?” Maverick says, grinning.

“I got her naked,” Eli tells him, lifting a brow.

I shift on his lap and suddenly find his erection pointing against my ass. Gasping in surprise, I move on his lap, but Eli pulls me right back.

“What’s wrong?” Ezra asks.

“Amazed by our beauty?” Cayson questions, wiggling his eyebrows.

“She’s uncomfortable,” Xander says, and I want to sink beneath the water to hide my face.

“Why is she uncomfortable?” Maverick asks, looking confused.

Eli reaches up and cups my breasts. “Because she can feel my cock.”

All eyes are on me.

I blush. “I wasn’t expecting it.”

“You weren’t expecting us to be hard?” Ezra asks in disbelief. “You’re naked. Of course we’re going to be hard.”

“I was hard when I saw you in the hall,” Maverick says, sounding nonchalant.

“I got a chubster watching you walk through the woods,” Cayson offers, grinning.

Xander shifts in the water. “I think I might always be hard around you.”

I laugh, mortified. “You guys aren’t really that… horny.”

Ezra rubs a thumb down my jaw. “Honey, you know it’s been awhile since we…

well, since we had you, right? We’ve been waiting for you to heal.

But then you walked in smelling like Eli, and it kind of got us all wondering if you were healed enough for sex.

” Then he rushes out, “Not that there’s any pressure. We’ll wait as long as you want.”

Eli begins to stroke my nipples under the water, and I shift again, that rod of his poking me, making his interest clear.

“I–I do think I’m ready for sex. I’m just a little nervous. There’s five of you.” I look up at them. “ Five . I mean, where does everything even… go?”

Eli chuckles and the low sound has goosebumps forming on my skin. “We can show you, beautiful. It’s not actually that complicated. Every time we’re together, we can try different things. Try to please you in different ways. Would you like that?”

His fingers pinch my nipples and a moan slips from my lips. “Yes.”

“If we’re not going to have sex soon, I just need to go take care of something,” Maverick says, his words rushed. “I don’t think I can handle listening to her moan like that again.”

“You guys want to have sex?” I ask.

Every single one of them nods their heads.

“But we’re in public!”

Cayson laughs. “Jelly Bean, we can absolutely do it in public. No one’s going to come up here. No one is going to see us.”

“But there’s no bed,” I say, glancing around.

Cayson gives me a smoldering look. “Just trust us, okay?”

“Okay,” I say, and I can practically hear all their dicks hardening.

Eli continues to touch me as he says, “But I think as exciting as our mate is, we should all intend to come in her pussy. If we want babies soon, the more of our seed we can give her the better.”

To my shock, all the men seem to like that idea, but I’m just trying to figure out how the hell that will work. I’ve only got one pussy, and there’s five of them. The math isn’t mathing.

Eli kisses my shoulder. “I also don’t think I should go in her ass. I think she needs to work up to that, given my size.”

“He’s not wrong,” Cayson mutters, since they’d all gotten a good look at his enormous pecker when we went skinny dipping.

Eli turns me around in his lap, so that I’m straddling him. Our eyes lock, and he kisses me long and hard before pulling back. He moves us so that he’s sitting on the soft shore, then, holding my eye contact, pushes slowly inside of me. I dig my nails into his back, gasping in air.

Ezra comes up behind me and reaches between us. His fingers find my clit, and he begins to slowly stroke me. The sensation makes me calm. It makes me stop thinking about the massive erection inside of me. I jump a little every time he rubs my clit, feeling my body relaxing.

My eyes flutter closed, and I feel Ezra’s erection against my ass. The knowledge almost makes me open my eyes again, but I’m too busy enjoying Ezra’s hands on me. Enjoying Eli sinking deeper and deeper into me.

“There, beautiful,” Eli murmurs. “You’ve taken all of me.”

I shudder and shift, feeling like he’s filling every inch of me.

But then Ezra slides a finger into my ass, and I tense again, shocking as sparks of pleasure awaken in my body.

Eli doesn’t move as Ezra works my ass, slowly adding more and more fingers to the first until I feel like I’m going to burst.

Maverick, Cayson, and Xander all gather around us. Their hands reach out, and they grasp my breasts. They touch me where Ezra had been, making my clit throb. I swear to the gods, Xander has magic hands. For as quiet as he is, he knows just where to touch me to make me feel like I’m losing my mind.

Suddenly, Ezra pulls his fingers out of my ass, and I whimper, missing the feeling of being so full. But I don’t have long to wait before he presses his cock into my ass, easing into me as slowly as Eli eased into my pussy.

I continue to dig my nails into Eli, feeling every inch of Ezra’s enormous length.

When he reaches his hilt, we’re all breathing fast. I lean back, allowing Maverick and Cayson better access to my breasts, and then lean down, sucking on them with abandon, moving from one cock to another, taking them deeply into my mouth, before switching again.

All of it makes me feel like I’m losing my mind.

I start to work myself against the cocks inside me, unable to pull in a deep breath, feeling like every nerve in my body is being touched.

Xander pinches my clit lightly, and I moan, my head spinning.

“Remember,” Eli grits out, “we want your cum in her pussy.”

And then Eli and Ezra start to work their cocks inside of me. If I was standing, my shaking knees would’ve crumbled. The sensation makes me feel like the whole world is falling down around me, and I don’t even care, because it feels that good.

My orgasm hits. I scream, needing to release the pressure inside of me. It feels like a balloon that’s suddenly popped. My muscles clench and release on the cocks inside of me, milking them for their seed.

Eli cries out my name, and I feel him explode inside of me.

He keeps pumping, and his warm cum makes me even hotter.

When he finishes, without a word, he pulls out of me.

Ezra pulls out too, and they spin me around.

As I’m braced against Eli, Ezra leans me back, lifting one of my legs, and fucking my pussy as hard as he can.

Another orgasm explodes, sending tremors through my body.

Ezra comes with a groan, and his scent explodes over me.

Ezra barely has time to pull out when Xander pushes inside me. His movements are desperate, one hand gripping my leg, the other on my belly. He doesn’t stop pumping until I say his name, wracked by another orgasm that makes my toes curl.

My head is still spinning when Cayson slips inside of me. He lifts both my legs, pressing them high over my head. The position switches my angle, and as he pumps into me, I feel myself squirting as another orgasm moves through me. This one leaves my vision black as I feel his hot cum inside of me.

Cayson releases me, and Maverick takes over. I almost tell them to stop, that I can’t imagine having another orgasm, but that big cock of his knows just what to do, and I’m screaming his name as I come flying over the edge. As I return to earth, I feel him coming inside of me with a guttural sound.

Then I lay, panting, wondering what the hell just happened.

“Is that normal?” I sputter. “Five fucking orgasms?”

Eli chuckles behind me. “For you, it will be.”

Holy shit. What have I gotten myself into?