Page 88

Pullman, Washington

T he WSU police chief, Gary Jenkins, is finishing up for the day when he sees that James Fry is calling his cell phone.

“Can you meet at our police department?” Fry asks.

Jenkins and Fry are old friends. Jenkins was recently reassigned to WSU, but prior to that, he ran the Pullman Police Department for twelve years.

It’s highly unusual for Fry to be as secretive and tight-lipped as he’s been about the Idaho Four, as the victims are coming to be known, but the chiefs have helped each other out on dozens of cases. Jenkins knows what his friend is trying to prevent: somehow tipping off the murderer.

So, as he drives over to the Moscow police station, he assumes Fry’s holding a second multiagency briefing, similar to the one where they asked for help searching for the white Hyundai Elantra.

But when Fry meets Jenkins at the front door of the station, the WSU chief senses this is different.

Jenkins follows Fry upstairs and into the conference room and sees a sea of faces. He realizes the entire team of investigators is gathered there, waiting for him.

What they are about to tell him, Fry says, is completely confidential, not to be shared even with his agency.

In that instant he realizes why he’s there.

They’ve found whoever did this.

And this person is at WSU. On his turf.

His heart sinks.

Brett Payne says, “We think we know who the suspect is, and he’s in WSU housing.”

And then he says his name: “Bryan Kohberger.”

Odd name, Jenkins thinks. But it’s an odd familiar name. It rings a bell, and then it comes to him.

“I know that name,” he tells the people in the room.

He sees astonishment on their faces.

“I think I interviewed him for an internship position when I was Pullman chief. I probably have his résumé and cover letter in my files.”

He goes straight back to his office and sends them over.

Payne and the team receive them, and their contents make it straight onto Payne’s draft affidavit, the one he’ll submit providing evidence to justify an arrest warrant for Kohberger.

It already contains what the police have discovered about the path of the Hyundai Elantra, Kohberger’s cell phone records, and what Dylan Mortensen saw that night.

Payne now adds to it the following:

Pursuant to records provided by a member of the interview panel for Pullman Police Department, we learned that Kohberger’s past education included undergraduate degrees in psychology and cloud-based forensics.

These records also showed Kohberger wrote an essay when he applied for an internship with the Pullman Police Department in the fall of 2022.

Kohberger wrote in his essay he had interest in assisting rural law enforcement agencies with how to better collect and analyze technological data in public safety operations.

Kohberger also posted a Reddit survey which can be found by an open-source internet search.

The survey asked for participants to provide information to “understand how emotions and psychological traits influence decision making when committing a crime.”

While Payne is writing, Jenkins is sitting in front of his computer, already running his to-do list through his mind.

He’s getting ready for what he’ll say when he’s allowed to share what he knows and for when his team gets the green light to write the warrants for the Moscow team to search Kohberger’s home and office.

Thank God he’d spoken to the guy in charge of camera security along Stadium Way, the main street in Pullman.

Soon after the murders they’d agreed it might be worth holding on to the footage of the night of the murders beyond the regular retention of sixty days.

He sees in his databases that the Pullman cops pulled over Kohberger in October. And he now sees that his guys, Officers Tiengo and Whitman, had identified the car a few weeks back.

WSU’s community is going to freak out when Kohberger is arrested. Jenkins knows this. He’s got a team of counselors on standby for the cops; he’ll almost certainly have to offer their services to the university.

He goes back to his database. What else was there about this guy that was missed?

There was a break-in near his apartment reported recently. Wasn’t there some story about a student being followed to her car?

What else?

His train of thought is interrupted by his phone. It’s Fry, thanking him for Kohberger’s résumé and cover letter. “No problem,” says Jenkins.

“Oh, and Gary, one more thing,” says Fry, letting out a small chuckle: “Aren’t you glad you didn’t accept his application?”

“More than you know,” replies Jenkins.