Page 62 of Accidental Theirs

I grin. “About our date?”

“Kind of.”

“I’m surprised. You seemed so sure that it was a one-time thing.”

She shrugs. “Maybe it was. Maybe it wasn’t. I don’t know. All I know is that I want to spend some more time with you.”

“What about them?” I don’t know if it’s simple jealousy or envy that rushes through me when she pauses.

“I want to spend more time with them, too. I want to see all of you, see where things go.”

My heart drops to my toes.

So, it wasn’t that she realized how much she liked me andwanted to date only me. She wants to spend more time with all of us.

But at the end of the day, sharing Olivia means that I still get to have her, so...

“Fair enough.”

“You’re not upset?”

“I’m not exactly over the moon about you seeing them, too, but I’m willing to throw my hat in the ring.”

She smiles. “Really? I thought maybe you’d be the holdout, since you don’t really like me like that.”

I frown at her. “What are you talking about?”

“I know you only did it to make me happy.” She looks away. “I know you don’t really want me.”

“Olivia.”

She won’t look at me. In fact, I have a horrifying realization that she’s about to cry.

“Olivia.Baby.”

I get down on my knees and crawl over to her, placing my hands on her thighs and looking up at her in a reverse of what she’d done earlier.

“Look at me.”

She doesn’t, and for a moment, I think she will ask me to leave, but her eyes finally meet mine, and she sniffles.

I squeeze her leg just a bit. “You have no idea what I want.”

“Tell me.” A breath.

“I’ve wanted you since the first moment I saw you.” The words come out of me before I can stop them.

I shouldn’t tell her this. I shouldn’t let her know how much I really want her. She could choose one of them, rip it all away.

Her eyes widen. “Liar.”

I grunt, my hands kneading the flesh of her thighs as I spread her legs.

She gasps but doesn’t protest, spreading them wider as I reach under her skirt.

I hook my thumbs into either side of her panties and tug them down and off her before spreading her thighs again.

I look down at her sex, which is already glistening, and a shudder of desire runs down my spine, making goosebumps pop up along my arms and the back of my neck.