Page 41

T he morning dawned clear and crisp, autumn sunlight gilding the formal gardens of Sutcliffe Manor.

Chilton stood at his study window, watching groundsmen clearing fallen leaves from the pathways, their methodical work creating order from nature's seasonal disarray.

Today he would attempt a similar restoration in his own life, sweeping away the layers of influence that had accumulated through years of deference to Caroline's judgment.

He had not slept well. Anticipation of the coming confrontation had kept his mind active through the night. By morning, however, his resolve had solidified into calm certainty. The path forward might not be easy, but it was increasingly clear.

"My lord." Simmons appeared at the study door. "The estate ledgers you requested are prepared in the library. Mr. Matthews is waiting to review them with you."

"Thank you, Simmons. Please inform him I'll be there directly."

"And shall I have refreshments prepared for Lady Hurst's arrival at three?"

"Tea in the blue drawing room, I think. And perhaps some of those almond biscuits she favours."

As Simmons withdrew, Chilton gathered the notes he had made during his restless night. Caroline would arrive expecting to find him receptive to guidance, perhaps slightly embarrassed by his behaviour at Linford Park. She would be disappointed on both counts.

In the library, Matthews awaited with the estate ledgers open before him, clearly curious about this unprecedented morning review. Typically, such financial discussions occurred quarterly, with Chilton offering cursory attention before approving Matthews' recommendations.

"Good morning, Matthews. Thank you for assembling these on such short notice."

"Of course, my lord. May I ask what specific aspects interest you today?"

"Several, in fact," Chilton said, consulting his notes. "First, the charitable allocations fund—I'd like a detailed accounting of its current balance and annual expenditures for the past five years."

Matthews blinked, clearly surprised. "I can provide that, my lord, though the information is somewhat scattered throughout various entries."

"Then let's gather it. I should also like to review the discretionary spending accounts, particularly those designated for estate improvements."

For the next two hours, Chilton immersed himself in the financial minutiae of Sutcliffe's operations with an attention to detail that visibly startled his steward. Line by line, he traced the flow of resources through his estate, asking pointed questions about allocations and priorities.

"This reserve fund," Chilton said, indicating a substantial sum carried forward annually. "It's grown considerably over the past decade. What is its intended purpose?"

Matthews shifted uncomfortably. "It was established by your father as a contingency against poor harvests or unexpected expenses. Lady Caroline has suggested maintaining it at current levels as a prudent safeguard."

"I see. And these entertainment expenses—they've increased nearly thirty percent since I assumed the title, despite hosting fewer formal gatherings. Can you explain the discrepancy?"

"Various social obligations, my lord. Lady Caroline felt it important to maintain certain appearances during your early years as baron, to establish your position among neighbouring gentry."

"My sister has been quite active in estate management decisions, it seems," Chilton observed neutrally.

"She has always had Sutcliffe's best interests at heart, my lord," Matthews replied carefully. "In your father's absence, her guidance has been influential."

"Indeed." Chilton closed the ledger. "Thank you for your thoroughness, Matthews. This has been most illuminating. I'll require an hour of private reflection before luncheon."

Left alone in the library, Chilton processed what he had learned.

The financial review had confirmed his suspicions: Caroline's influence extended far deeper into Sutcliffe's operations than he had realized.

From charitable allocations to investment decisions, from staff appointments to tenant relations, his sister's hand had guided virtually every aspect of estate management during his early years as baron.

What had begun as necessary support for a young man thrust unexpectedly into responsibility had calcified into something problematic—a parallel authority that had allowed Chilton the illusion of control while actual decisions were shaped by Caroline's priorities.

The realization brought a curious sense of clarity. He had ceded authority because it had been easier than asserting it. His complicity in Caroline's control was as much his own failing as hers.

That would change today.

At precisely three o'clock, the sound of carriage wheels on gravel announced his sister's arrival.

Chilton remained in the library, deliberately breaking with the custom of greeting her at the door.

It was a small assertion of independence, but a meaningful one—Caroline would recognize it immediately.

When Simmons announced her ten minutes later, her expression already held a hint of displeasure.

"Chilton," she said as she entered, "it's unlike you not to greet me properly."

"My apologies, Caroline," he replied, rising to kiss her cheek. "I was in the midst of some estate correspondence that couldn't be interrupted."

She studied him with the shrewd gaze that had assessed his adequacy since childhood, noting his informal coat, the papers spread across the desk, the absence of his eager-to-please demeanour.

"Estate matters on the day of my visit? How unusual," she observed. "Typically, you prefer to avoid such tedium when company is expected."

"Responsibilities don't always conform to social schedules," Chilton replied mildly. "Besides, I've recently gained a new appreciation for the importance of direct oversight."

Caroline's eyes narrowed. "Have you indeed? How... commendable. Though I hope this sudden dedication won't prevent our discussing the matters that brought me here."

"Not at all. In fact, I believe they may be related. Shall we adjourn to the drawing room for tea?"

The blue drawing room awaited with tea already laid out, the silver service polished to a mirror shine, the almond biscuits arranged on a Wedgwood plate precisely as Caroline preferred. She noted these details with approval as she settled onto the sofa.

"Mrs. Hobbs remembers my preferences," she observed. "A sign of a well-managed household."

"Indeed," Chilton agreed, handing her a cup prepared exactly as she liked it. "Though I believe credit belongs to Simmons rather than Mrs. Hobbs."

He seated himself not opposite her as was their custom, but in a chair positioned at a slight angle—close enough for conversation but with sufficient distance to establish separation. Another small but deliberate break with pattern.

Caroline sipped her tea, her gaze assessing him. "You seem different, Chilton. There's a tension about you I haven't seen before."

"Not tension," he corrected gently. "Clarity, perhaps. Recent events have given me cause to reconsider certain assumptions."

"Ah," Caroline set down her cup with a delicate click. "We come to it at last. Your behaviour at Linford Park."

"Among other things."

"I had hoped you might have recognized the impropriety of your actions by now," Caroline continued, her tone shifting to the one she had used to correct his childhood missteps. "Your defence of that Martin woman against legitimate social concerns was most unseemly."

"Did it create discomfort?" Chilton's voice remained calm despite the spark of irritation her dismissive reference to Meredith kindled. "I observed such only from you, Caroline. The other guests seemed quite impressed by Miss Martin's intelligence and passion for her cause."

Caroline's lips thinned. "Passion without propriety is hardly admirable. The woman clearly used the wedding gathering to advance her own interests—securing patronage for her educational schemes and, I strongly suspect, attempting to engage your interest on a more personal level."

"And that concerns you because...?" he asked, deliberately leaving the question open-ended.

"Because you are Baron Sutcliffe," Caroline replied with exaggerated patience.

"Your position requires alignment with suitable connections—social, financial, and matrimonial.

Miss Martin, whatever her scholarly qualifications, lacks the background and propriety to be an appropriate association for someone of your standing. "

Chilton took a slow sip of his tea, allowing the silence to extend just long enough to signal that her pronouncement would not go unchallenged.

"I find it interesting," he said finally, "that you presume to determine what constitutes an 'appropriate association' for me. Particularly in matters of a personal nature."

Caroline blinked, clearly taken aback by his direct resistance. "I speak only out of concern for your well-being and the reputation of the Sutcliffe name. As I have always done."

"Yes," Chilton agreed. "You have always done so. Since our father's death, you have guided virtually every aspect of my life and this estate's management—from my education to my social connections, from financial decisions to tenant relations. Your influence has been comprehensive."

Something in his tone must have alerted Caroline to the shifting ground beneath this conversation. She straightened, her expression growing wary.

"I did what was necessary," she said carefully. "You were young when Father died, unprepared for the responsibilities thrust upon you. Someone had to ensure Sutcliffe's stability during that vulnerable period."