Page 73 of Their Reckless Thief (The Below #1)

A muscle worked in Luca’s jaw as he ground his teeth, but finally, he relented, dropping heavily into the chair.

Vincenzo turned his attention back to me, his gaze dragging slowly down my naked body. “Stand up.”

I tried to obey, but it was hard to get my balance with my hands tied behind my back. Dorian reached down to help me, but Vincenzo stepped forward, gently lifting me to my feet.

I glanced at Luca. His eyes were dark and hooded as he took in the sight of me, and hell if that didn’t make my nipples hard.

They wanted me. There was no denying it. Each of them was breathing heavier, their pupils dilating as they took me in. And damn it all to hell, I wanted them, too. If this were to be my punishment, then I’d never obey Vincenzo’s wishes ever again.

Vincenzo moved closer, but he didn’t touch me.

“Celeste Callahan, you’ve been found guilty of stealing from Vincenzo Moretti, Lord of the Night.

There are many options at my disposal for your punishment.

The option I’ve chosen is to show you who has the power here, who is in control, and who is not.

Unfortunately for you, dolcezza , you are not the one in charge.

” He took a deep breath and closed the gap between us, dragging a finger from the top of my shoulder down my arm and around to my stomach.

His finger stopped just above my pelvis.

“I’m going to take my time and enjoy every fucking second of this. ”

Goosebumps erupted all over my body, and my nipples tightened even more. I nodded, not daring to say a word.

“Dorian, chair.” Vincenzo pointed to the chair across the room, and Dorian obediently dragged it to Vincenzo’s side. He took a seat and patted his lap. “Come here, Celeste.”

I moved slowly to his side and lowered myself onto his lap, his erection pressing into my ass.

“I’m going to flip you over now.” Before I could protest, he grabbed my waist and twisted me over and pushed me onto his lap, so that I was facing the floor with my ass in the air.

He held me firmly at the waist for a few moments.

“This might hurt, Celeste. In fact, I guarantee it will.”

He reared back and slapped my ass. I yelped at the sting but tried to hold still as heat pooled between my thighs. Why the fuck was this turning me on? Vincenzo leaned over and whispered in my ear again. “I bet you liked that, didn’t you, dolcezza ? I bet you’re dripping for me right now.”

Without a warning, he slapped my ass again.

Vincenzo hissed out a breath. “Perhaps I could make this a little more enjoyable for you, Celeste. Would you like that?”

“Mmm,” I moaned. Yes, I wanted more. I didn’t even care what he had in mind.

I couldn’t see anything except the floor, but my senses were heightened, blood rushing to my head.

He rubbed his hand over my burning ass a few times before dipping lower.

He spread me apart with his fingers and slid his middle finger inside me.

I gasped at the change in sensation as he slowly moved in and out of me.

“You’re fucking soaked for me, dolcezza .” He brought his other hand down on my ass again. The pain and pleasure melted together into something indescribable, and I let out another moan.

“Hmm. I think she likes it,” he said to Dorian and Luca. “Maybe I’m not punishing her enough.”

I felt him slide two more fingers into me, and I gasped at the stretch. “Fuck, Vincenzo!”

He slapped my ass again, curling his fingers inside me. “Look how wet she gets for us when I spank that perfect ass.”

He slapped me again and again, his fingers picking up speed, hitting the right spot over and over again. My breath became ragged as I teetered on the edge of an orgasm.

Vincenzo must have sensed my impending release because he abruptly pulled his fingers out of me. When I cried out in disappointment, he pulled me up and sat me on his lap, directly on top of his rock-hard cock.

“Dorian, come here.”

Dorian met my gaze and moved forward without saying a word, licking his lips as he stopped in front of me.

His cheeks were flushed with desire. Vincenzo grabbed my legs, pulling my feet up and planting them on either side of him on the chair.

The position had me leaning back against his chest as he gripped my thighs and gently pushed my legs apart, exposing me to Dorian and Luca.

I glanced at Luca. He raked a hand through his hair, his impressive erection straining against his jeans.

Vincenzo gripped my ass, opening me even wider. “Dorian, I want you to pleasure Celeste with your mouth.”

Dorian lowered himself to the ground in front of me, reaching out to gently touch my inner thighs.

He leaned in and slowly brushed his lips against my fold, breathing in my scent.

“You’re already so fucking wet, sweetheart.

” His tongue darted out, tracing a line up my slit to my clit.

I groaned as he flicked his tongue over that sensitive bundle of nerves.

Luca bit his lip as he watched us. He unfastened his belt buckle, then pulled his jeans down to release his cock.

He stroked himself slowly as he watched Dorian pleasuring me.

I moaned, unable to contain the sounds. Vincenzo let go of my ass and ran his hands up to my breasts.

He squeezed them gently, rolling my nipples under his fingertips and grinding his erection into my ass.

It was all too much. I wanted to grab the back of Dorian’s head and pull him closer, but my hands were still tied behind my back. The pleasure coiled tighter and tighter in my body until I almost couldn’t take it. Dorian sucked gently on my clit, and my every muscle tightened.

“Stop,” Vincenzo ordered, his hands leaving my breasts. “We can’t allow Celeste to get what she wants now, can we? That wouldn’t be much of a punishment.”

I glanced at Luca again. He stopped stroking himself, as if he didn’t want to give himself release until I got mine.

I wanted him to come closer, wanted to wrap my mouth around his massive cock again.

Gods, I wanted to feel him hitting the back of my throat as I took every inch of him as deep as my throat would allow.

Vincenzo placed me on my feet. “Celeste, I want you to let Dorian fuck your mouth. I think he deserves it, don’t you?”

I nodded and moved toward Dorian. He quickly undid his pants, pulling his cock out and fisting it. I started to drop to my knees, but Vincenzo stopped me. “No, dolcezza . You’ll be sitting. On my cock.”

My eyes widened as I tried to make sense of his instructions. I turned in time to see Vincenzo lower his pants. He sat back into the chair and patted his naked thighs. “Sit.”

When I didn’t obey immediately, he grabbed my hips and pulled me backward.

He gripped his cock and used his other hand to guide me onto him.

I sat slowly, taking him in, inch by inch.

He was so fucking thick. I gasped at the sensation of him stretching me wider than ever before.

By the time I’d lowered myself completely, I had to close my eyes and catch my breath.

I didn’t have much time to recover before Dorian rubbed his erection against my lips.

“Open your mouth for Dorian, dolcezza .”

I did as I was told and parted my lips. Squeezing my eyes shut, I tried to relax my throat.

Dorian didn’t waste any time thrusting deep into my throat.

I gagged, tears pricking my eyes. Vincenzo reached around and pressed his middle finger against my clit.

He didn’t move it, just held it there, applying pressure.

I wanted to move, needed the friction desperately, but he held me in place so Dorian could fuck my mouth.

My feet dangled helplessly off the ground, and my hands were still tied behind my back.

I had no leverage to move against Vincenzo.

Sensing my desire, Vincenzo took control, grabbing my waist with his free hand and guiding me up and down.

I groaned loudly on Dorian’s dick as Vincenzo matched the rhythm of Dorian’s cock gliding in and out of my mouth.

I hadn’t known I could feel so much, and it overwhelmed me.

That familiar tension coiled low in my belly, and I moaned in ecstasy.

It was the wrong thing to do because they both stopped moving.

“That’s enough,” Vincenzo ordered.

Dorian pulled out of my mouth and stepped to the side. Luca was now bracing himself against the chair with one hand and holding himself with the other. He’d stopped, too.

Vincenzo lifted me off his cock and stood me on the floor.

“You didn’t think we’d let you come, did you, dolcezza ?

” He spun me around. Lust blazed in his eyes, and I gasped as he grazed his knuckles over my nipples.

“Maybe we’ve pushed you too far. I don’t think I’ve ever been near a creature so turned on, so dripping fucking wet as you are. ”

Gods, he was right. My arousal dripped down my thighs, and if I could’ve pulled my hands free, I would’ve fucked every single one of them over and over again until I could no longer move.

I’d never been so horny in my entire life.

I wanted all of them, wanted everything they could give, and I wanted it all at once.

Vincenzo studied me while he decided on his next move. “Up against the wall, Celeste.”

I walked slowly, deliberately to the wall and pressed my face and breasts against it, pressing my ass out, hoping one of them would give me what I wanted.

Vincenzo walked behind me, his hard length pressing against my back.

“How many ways can you take me, dolcezza ?” He ran a hand over my wet pussy and sighed into my ear.

“I think you can handle me.” His finger slowly traced my opening until he reached my asshole.

I gasped. Surely not. I’d never taken anyone that way.

The thought made my heart race, but not with dread.

I pushed back against his finger, relishing the sensation.

He slowly slipped his finger into me, and I hissed.

After a few tentative thrusts, he slowly removed his finger.

“Oh, yes. I do believe you can take me. First, I need you completely ready. Dorian, lay down on the floor.”

Vincenzo released me, and I turned to see Dorian doing as he was told, lying flat with his back on the floor, his cock standing erect.

“Celeste, straddle Dorian. Fuck him slowly. Do not get carried away.”

I swallowed as I walked to Dorian and straddled him. He stared up at me expectantly, and with what I feared was adoration. “Come on, sweetheart. I’m ready for you.”

I lowered myself onto Dorian’s long cock, hissing as he filled me completely. He shut his eyes and ran his hands up my legs. “Your pussy is so fucking perfect.”

I slid up and down his shaft, arching my back. Dorian’s hands crept up my stomach and cupped my breasts. The warmth of him inside me was all too much, and I could finally, finally , move at the speed I wanted. I was so fucking close to coming. The sensation had my toes curling.

“Stop.” Vincenzo stepped forward. “Don’t move a muscle.”

I sat perfectly still, Dorian’s pulsing dick buried deep inside me. Vincenzo lowered to the floor behind me. “Lean forward, Celeste. Lie on Dorian’s chest.”

He pushed the small of my back as I lowered myself onto Dorian. Vincenzo tugged at the cord around my wrists, freeing my hands. “Don’t make me regret this, dolcezza . I am still in control. You do what I say.”

I nodded, pressing my hands against Dorian’s chest and staring into his eyes.

He ran his hands through my hair. “Do you want this, Celeste?”

“More than anything.”

With that answer, Vincenzo pressed his body against mine and slowly entered me from behind. I gasped and moaned at the pressure and stinging sensation.

“Almost there, Celeste. You’re taking me so fucking well.”

He stopped moving when he was completely inside me. My heart raced, and I gasped for air. The sensation of them both filling me was unlike anything I’d ever experienced.

“Celeste.” Vincenzo’s breath was hot against my ear, sending a shiver down my spine. “I want you to fuck Dorian while I fuck you.”

I moved against Dorian as Vincenzo thrust so achingly slow.

Dorian rolled my nipples between his fingers while Vincenzo reached around and massaged my clit in a circular motion.

Every nerve in my body stood on end. A fire I’d never felt before took hold in my lower abdomen.

With each thrust, each squeeze, each pressured motion, I could feel myself coming undone.

“Are you going to come for us, Celeste?” Vincenzo asked. “Show us who’s a good girl. I want to hear you scream. Come for me, dolcezza .”

He thrust hard into my ass, and the world tilted on its axis. Every muscle in my body clenched around them. My vision went black as my orgasm took hold. I screamed just as I heard Luca behind me, releasing with a guttural grunt.

“Fuck!”

Vincenzo and Dorian weren’t far behind. They grabbed onto me, held on as if I was their lifeline as they pounded into me and spilled into me.