Page 28 of The Bro Date (Best Bros Forever #2)

“Shane,” he breathes out like a prayer, hanging his head with desire. His wet curls drip water onto my sheets, and his body glistens with moisture.

I can’t take it any longer, I’m just as desperate as he is, so I spread him open and swipe my tongue up his crease, starting with his balls.

“ Ungh! Fuck! ” Toby cries out, panting and spreading his legs further apart to give me more access.

I focus on his hole, circling my tongue before I stiffen it and prod at his entrance until my tongue wiggles its way in, and I start to fuck him with it.

The moans and cries that pour from Toby’s mouth sound inhuman.

Animalistic. I keep him spread with one hand, continuing to rim him within an inch of his life while I reach around to stroke his cock with my other hand.

“Oh God. Shane. Oh God. Please. I need you to fuck me. Please, fuck me, ” Toby begs as his thighs begin to shake. I stand up and grab the lube from the bedside table, popping the cap and pouring some on my finger as well as Toby’s hole.

He hisses when the cool liquid drips down his crease, moaning when I start to rub it in and press a finger inside him. “Mmm. Shane,” he groans, dropping his head and sticking his ass up even further.

I fuck him with one finger before pulling out and pushing another into him. “You like that?” I ask, continuing to fuck him with two fingers.

Just as he’s about to speak, I push my fingers all the way in, twisting and curling them until I find his spot. Toby’s words come out in a garbled cry, and he starts to bounce his ass on my hand.

“That’s it, baby,” I encourage. “Make yourself feel good. Think you can take three?”

Toby nods frantically, continuing to move fast until I slow him down by grabbing his hip and slipping my fingers out.

He whimpers at the loss. “ Shh, baby. I got you.” I press three fingers against his hole, meeting resistance.

“You can do it, just relax your muscles and bear down like with the toy.” Toby takes a deep breath, and I push forward, three of my thick digits sinking into him and stretching him open.

I press his upper back down, making him lift his ass even higher.

I spread my fingers, stretching him further and making his breathing pick up.

What a fucking view.

“Shane. I’m so full,” he nearly sobs, but he hasn’t felt anything yet compared to my dick.

“Are you ready for me to fuck you, butterfly?” I gently slip my fingers out before he can even answer, and Toby collapses to the bed as if my hand was the only thing holding him up.

“Yes. Please, Shane. Fuck me. Please. ”

I push one of Toby’s knees up so that it’s bent as high as it can go. “Now arch your back and pop your ass out for me, baby.”

Toby does as instructed, and I crawl between his open legs, grabbing both hips. I admire his pulsing, stretched hole. Ready and waiting for me. Gripping the base of my thoroughly lubed-up cock, I give it a few pumps before pressing against his hole.

I pause for a second. This may be redundant after the other night, but I respect him and ask, nonetheless. “Do you want me to use a condom? I’m negative, but it’s your decision.”

“No. I trust you. Always. I want to feel you inside me, with nothing between us, and I want you to fill me with your seed.”

Holy fucking shit.

I growl like an actual dog, baring my teeth and all.

Slowly pressing forward, I meet resistance, even though he’s nice and open.

Toby whimpers at the pressure, clenching up and pulling away. “I can’t do it,” he whines. “It’s too big.”

“ Shhh. Yes, you can.” I hover over him and kiss his neck, rubbing a hand down his thigh and ass, massaging him. “Just relax, Tobes. Take a deep breath and remember to bear down when you feel me pushing against you.” I reach around, stroking his cock and getting him hard again.

“Okay. I’m ready” Toby whispers, wiggling his ass against me.

I try again, continuing to push past the first ring of muscle, making Toby cry out as I pop inside. I pause, glancing down and staring in awe at my cock disappearing inside of his ass.

I almost can’t believe it.

“ Oh God! Shane! ” Toby shouts, and I remain frozen, allowing his body to get used to me before I continue.

“You’re doing so good. So fucking good, ” I murmur, rubbing a hand down his spine, admiring the sexy arch of his back.

After a few deep breaths, he’s finally ready. “Keep going,” he breathes out, and I push my hips forward, gliding the rest of the way into him until I bottom out.

The wail that comes out of him sends goosebumps shivering down my spine and almost makes me blow my load.

Holy shit. He’s so fucking tight.

“You alright?” I ask, completely out of breath, even though I haven’t started fucking him yet.

Toby remains silent for a moment, his cheek pressed to the mattress and his eyes pinched closed.

“Talk to me,” I urge, starting to get a little worried. “You okay, baby?”

“I-I’ve never felt so full,” he whimpers. “I want you to stay inside me forever.”

Toby contracts his inner muscles around my cock and I grunt, squeezing his hips even harder.

“Fuck me, Shane,” he finally says.

I stare at the place where we’re connected, my dick completely disappearing inside him. I pull back gently and press forward once again, my eyes rolling into the back of my head.

So fucking tight.

Continuing the gentle pace, I kiss his neck and nibble on his ear, leisurely fucking him. Nothing too hard and nothing too rough.

“More,” Toby whispers.

“More what?” I ask, continuing to be gentle and slow. “Tell me. I need to hear you say it.”

“ Harder. I may be clumsy, but I’m not made of glass. Fuck me harder, Shane!”

I do as he says and pull back quickly, surging forward fast and hard.

Toby spreads his legs further, and I grab hold of his hips, pistoning in and out of him as fast as I can.

I fuck him hard , spearing into him before slowing down and grinding my pelvis into his sensitive rim.

Reaching around, I grab hold of his cock and stroke him in time with my thrusts.

“I’m gonna come, Shane. I’m gonna come,” Toby chants over and over until his muscles constrict around my cock, triggering my own orgasm. We both cry out at the same time, Toby’s high-pitched wails mixing with my low grunts and moans.

I’ve never come so hard in all my life.

Not even close.

My dick starts to soften, and I carefully slip out of Toby’s ass, making him wince. “You okay?” I ask. Toby doesn’t speak, only nods into the pillow while he lies motionless in his own release. “My turn to take care of you,” I murmur, and Toby just hums with his eyes closed. “Don’t move.”

Grabbing a towel, I quickly wipe myself off before wrapping it around my waist and rushing to the bathroom to clean up and relieve myself. I return with a couple of warm washcloths for Toby, finding him exactly where I left him.

I get a clean pair of boxers from my dresser drawer and slip them on before climbing back in bed. “You awake?” I whisper, gently rubbing his back.

“Mhm,” Toby responds with a sleepy smile, and his eyes still closed.

“Gonna clean you up,” I warn him, spreading his cheeks and making him jump. “Shh. I just need to make sure everything’s okay and get you cleaned up.”

Toby relaxes and allows me to inspect him. He’s a little red and puffy, but I’m sure that’s to be expected. I use the second washcloth to wipe his spent cock and get as much off the sheets as I can manage.

“Let’s move to your bed. Gonna stick the sheets in the wash,” I tell him after we lie there spooning for a little while. “Think I heard Spence and Jake come home, so make sure you get dressed,” I warn him, and he groans.

“We need more privacy,” Toby complains, and I couldn’t agree more.

Toby slips on one of my oversized T-shirts, wearing it like a nightgown. I throw on some basketball shorts and a T-shirt of my own. Toby sneaks off to his room while I take my bed apart, lugging the sheets downstairs to the laundry room.

Luckily, I make it back to Toby’s room without an encounter with our roommates. I’m not in the mood to rehash what happened tonight. I’m currently in my own world with Toby, and I never want to leave it.

“Hey,” I murmur as I step into his bedroom with a crooked smile.

“Hey,” Toby replies, a warm blush filling his cheeks, and I find it so endearing after what we just did in my bed.

“Ready to cuddle?” I ask, undressing down to my underwear.

“Yeah. But take those off, too,” Toby says with two mischievous dimples I can’t say no to.

I step out of my boxer briefs, my dick getting hard once again. He pulls the covers back, revealing his own naked body and half-hard cock. I climb in, wrapping him up in my embrace.

“I like feeling small in your arms,” Toby admits quietly, further sinking into me. “I like feeling safe.”

I squeeze him tighter, every atom in my body feeling the universe push us closer together until I can’t deny it any longer. Can’t deny us .

Like a thief in the night, my world is forever changed. It’s in this very moment that reality hits me.

I love him, and in a way, I think I always have.

“Can I tell you something?” I whisper vulnerably.

“Of course,” Toby replies, his brows creased and face tense as he sits up and waits for me to speak.

I push myself up, too, and lean against the headboard, giving him a half-smile. I hold my palm out, and Toby places his hand in mine, scooting closer.

“It’s taken me a while to admit this to myself, but I think a part of me has always known it . . . I’m in love with you.”

“ What? ” Toby gasps, his eyes instantly welling up with tears. “You . . .”

“I’m in love with you, Tobias Livingston. You don’t have to say it back. I just needed you to know.” It feels like a weight I didn’t know I was carrying has been lifted from my shoulders.

“Of course I have to say it back,” he chuckles, the laugh turning into a sob. “I love you, too, Shane. So freaking much. I’ve loved you since high school and probably before. You have no idea.”

“ Butterfly, ” I whisper, memorizing his delicate features and glistening gaze in this movie-perfect moment.

Leaning forward, I kiss him softly, wrapping my arms around him and squeezing him tightly to my chest. “You’re my best friend, my lover, and the key to my happiness.

I want you to be my boyfriend, Toby. Will you?

” I ask, peering down into mesmerizing golden eyes.

“Yes, Shane. That would make me the happiest person in the world.”

I lean down and seal my lips to my boyfriend’s.

He’s mine now. And I will do everything in my power to keep him happy and safe.