Page 4 of Taming the Beasts (Crooked Point #3)

Thursday

Zoey

Shit. Shit, shit, shit! Bennett must have rewound the security camera footage. He knew I’d broken into his vault filled with relics.

This was bad. Really bad. But it was hard to worry when all I felt was pleasure.

Bennett thrust into me harder.

No one could think straight when they were being fucked.

And Bennett knew it. He knew how much I loved this.

How turned on I’d been waiting for him, with Ace deep inside of me and my lips wrapped around Huxley.

Bennett knew all of it. And he was using his cock to get a straight answer from me. My mind was complete mush.

I moaned as his fingers dug into my hips.

“The truth, Zoey.” Thrust. “Tell.” Thrust. “Me.” Thrust. “Now.”

I wanted to just tell him the truth. But I wasn’t even sure he’d believe me since I didn’t have the coin as proof. And Kebe was right. I didn’t want to get his hopes up. And maybe I was a little worried that curing them would change things. We’d only just started this relationship.

“Don’t make me repeat myself,” he said.

“I just wanted to prove that I could. ”

“Stop lying to me.”

“I’m not…”

He grabbed my hips and lifted me into his arms while he was still inside me. It just shifted him deeper.

Fuck. I buried my fingers in his hair and tightened my legs around his waist as he kicked his office door open.

I was vaguely aware of Huxley and Ace’s eyes on us as Bennett carried me around the counter and past several vaults. “How did you break in?” he asked.

“I stole Ace’s key.” I tried to grind against him, but he was holding me tightly in place.

He looked over at Ace and shook his head.

I was definitely not trying to get Ace in trouble.

I didn’t want them fighting. I knew what happened when they fought.

And I had no idea what Bennett shifting while he was inside of me would do.

I hadn’t exactly been looking at his dick when I’d seen him shift.

I was much too focused on his sharp teeth.

Shifting while fucking would probably just end with him immediately biting my throat. I swallowed hard.

Bennett stopped when he reached the vault I’d broken into earlier. “How did you know the code?” he asked and slammed my back against the cold, hard metal vault door.

God. This was exactly what I’d requested. I was really liking how this punishment was playing out.

“Zoey.” He gripped my chin tightly between his fingers.

“I saw you type it in. When you were showing me and Emma the relics.”

“You memorized it?”

“Yes. ”

“Hmm.” His eyes bore into mine. “Interesting.”

“I’m good at stuff like this. I want to be one of you.”

He slowly shook his head. “No, you really don’t.”

I didn’t think we were talking about thievery anymore. I was pretty sure he was referring to being a werecat. And he looked so damn sad about it. I knew he thought he was a monster. But he wasn’t. Not now, not ever. And it killed me that he couldn’t see how wonderful he was.

I clenched around him.

He groaned. “You’re not coming anytime soon, baby. So don’t even try.”

Bennett was going to be the death of me.

A buzzing noise echoed around the bank.

Even though we were in the middle of fucking, Bennett pulled out his phone. He swiped his thumb across the screen and stared at a message. His eyes met mine again. “Titan says you took something from the vault. What was it?”

Titan was rewatching the footage right now? I looked up at the camera. I wondered what he’d be thinking when he fast-forwarded to the present moment. I knew how much he liked watching. Just as much as I liked being watched.

Bennett groaned.

And I realized that the thought of Titan watching had me gripping Bennett tighter. This was why we all worked so well together. This is why I didn’t want anything to change.

He pulled me off the vault door. “Type in the code.” He grabbed one of my hands, removing it from his hair, and placed it in front of the display .

It only took me a few seconds to type it in.

The vault door hissed.

“Titan said he saw something in your hand. But he couldn’t make it out. Tell me what you took.”

“I didn’t take anything that belongs to you. I swear.” That was the truth. None of the stuff in that vault belonged to them. They’d stolen all of it.

Bennett lowered his eyebrows as he stared at me. And I swear he could see right into my soul.

“She took something,” Bennett said. He was looking at me, but he definitely wasn’t talking to me. “Check it out.” He stepped away from the door.

Ace and Huxley walked toward the vault. Huxley spun the wheel and there was a mechanical whooshing noise as the heavy metal door sprung forward.

Did they have an inventory sheet of everything in that vault? It almost seemed like a bad idea to write any of it down since it was all stolen. They’d accumulated those items over years. They couldn’t possibly know every single relic hidden in there.

Bennett slammed my back against the next vault door. His vault door. And then he gently kissed the side of my neck. The contrast of the cold hard metal and his soft kisses had me gripping him tight again.

“Tell me what you took,” he whispered against my skin before placing another kiss at the base of my neck.

“I didn’t take anything that was yours,” I said again. I still wanted to get to surprise them. “Bennett, I swear.”

He slammed into me again. “He saw a flash of silver in your hand, Zoey.”

The cameras must not have been great quality.

I hadn’t been waving the coin around or anything, but I had looked at it.

And Kebe had grabbed it. Did they know that?

Would they go after Kebe next? “I don’t know what he saw, but he’s wrong.

Titan isn’t exactly my biggest fan. I wouldn’t trust him for a second. ”

Bennett lifted his lips from my neck and frowned.

I regretted the words immediately. Titan had apologized for blackmailing me. He was just trying to protect his friends. We were all ready to move on. Bringing this up again wasn’t helping anything. But then Bennett’s features softened.

“I’m sorry,” Bennett said. “I wasn’t saying I trusted his word over yours.”

But he should trust Titan more. I had taken something. And now I’d just twisted everything even more.

“Let me give you this fantasy of yours.” His fingers tightened on my hips, bruising my skin. “Right here against the vault door like you requested.” He thrust into me again and again.

Fuck. It was hard to feel bad about what I’d said about Titan when Bennett’s cock was buried inside of me.

“You can come now, baby,” he said. He slid one of his hands from my waist to my stomach. His hand dipped beneath my thong. He thrust into me again as he traced circles around my clit.

I stared into the camera as I came. I’m sorry, Titan. But at least I’d given him a performance that he’d love.

Bennett thrust into me again and I felt his warm cum fill me.

His fingers fell from my clit and he ran them across the choker Huxley had given me.

A gift to ward off vampires, which I still felt seemed a little ironic.

Bennett’s fingers trailed along one of the crisscrossing straps of my lingerie.

“I like this on you. A gift from Huxley, I presume?”

I nodded.

He pulled on one of the straps to expose my left nipple. He leaned down and flicked his tongue against it.

I moaned and gripped him again.

“You still owe me a private session.” He let the strap snap back into place, making me moan again. And then he slowly pulled out of me and set me on my feet. “Huxley!” he called toward the vault.

Huxley walked out.

“Turn around, Zoey,” Bennett said. “Hands on the vault door. You need to let him finish too, baby.”

God I loved my boyfriends. I turned around and placed my hands against the cold metal. I arched my back.

Huxley slid his fingers through the slit in my thong.

“No need,” Bennett said. “She’s already soaked with my cum. Isn’t that right, Zoey?”

I nodded. Bennett and Ace had both filled me already. I wanted Huxley to fill me too. I arched my back more, jutting my ass higher in the air for him.

Huxley grabbed my hips and slammed into me from behind.

I pressed my palms hard against the vault door so I wouldn’t fall over.

“Fuck her hard,” Bennett said.

Huxley increased his pace.

“She did all this just to be taught a lesson.”

I moaned and pushed on the metal to match his thrusts.

“Everything was in place,” Ace said as he emerged from the vault. “As far as I could tell. ”

“As far as I could tell too,” Huxley said as he thrust into me even harder.

I loved being taught a lesson by the three of them. I loved how all their eyes were on me. And I loved how they didn’t mind sharing me. Would that always be the case?

Bennett touched the bottom of my chin so I’d look up at him.

“I’m sorry I didn’t believe you. I trust you, Zoey. With everything.”

Guilt gripped my chest. But it eased as soon as Huxley slammed into me again.

“Suck,” Bennett said and slid his thumb into my mouth. “We both know you always want more than one of us at once.”

He was right. I wrapped my lips around his thumb and stared into his eyes. I always wanted all of them. All five of them. I glanced at the camera. Was Titan watching? Was he wrapping his hand around his length, wishing I’d beg him next?

Huxley cursed under his breath as he lost control.

Bennett pulled his thumb out of my mouth, dragging my lower lip down. He released it and my lip fell back to place with a satisfying popping sound. He smiled down at me. “Time to go home and clean you up.”

“Oh,” I said and tensed. I couldn’t go back to their place right now. “Actually I need to…”

“Fuck, princess,” Huxley said and pulled out of me. “I swear her pussy was made to grip us.”

Us. I wanted all of us to always be an us. I cleared my throat. “I need to go home and… ”

“Your home is with us,” Bennett said. “We all discussed it after you left today.”

That was great. And I was so excited about it. All I wanted to do was move in with them and do this every day. But I needed to go talk to Kebe and King and do some research of my own.

“I can’t wait to spend the night.” I also couldn’t wait to see whose bed I’d be sharing.

Or maybe they had a room just for me? I had no idea what they had planned, or how they had gotten it together so quickly.

“But I just need to go grab a few things first.” And do everything else I just thought about.

“We’ll come with you,” Ace said. This time when he grabbed a tissue to help clean me up, Bennett didn’t stop him.

“We don’t trust your new roommate,” Huxley said.

Yeah, me either. But I needed to go talk to her. Without them. I laughed, hoping to play this off. “Well she certainly likes you,” I said.

Huxley stared at me. “What?”

“Nothing.” I sighed. “Really, I just need to head back to my place for a few minutes. Emma is there too, so you don’t have to worry about me being alone with my new roommate. And the three of you are missing the game.”

They all looked at each other.

Bingo.

Ace wiped up the wetness from my thigh. I really liked the way he took care of me. He tossed the tissue in the trash and turned to Bennett.

“Then we’ll all head back to your place after the game,” Bennett said .

What? No. That wasn’t what I’d said. I loved having five boyfriends, but it was really hard when they were all super possessive. I couldn’t really argue anymore without being suspicious though.

“Where did you leave your catsuit?” he asked. “As much as I love this, I don’t want you walking along Main Street in it for everyone else to see.”

“I’ll grab her stuff.” Huxley went into Bennett’s office to get my clothes that I’d stripped off earlier.

“Besides,” Bennett said. “I want to meet this new roommate of yours.”

God, Kebe would probably start flirting with him next. And ask to be patted down again.

Huxley walked back out of the office and handed me my black leather outfit.

I really hoped that Emma had the Kebe situation under control. Because Kebe had been acting so strangely that I was a little worried she was about to just hightail it out of town with the cure.