Page 63

“Yes. With renewed hope, despite Caroline’s continued opposition. I believed...” His voice cracked. “I truly believed Jane and I might resume where we had left off. But then...”

“Colonel Fitzwilliam arrived,” Darcy supplied when Bingley seemed unable to continue.

“Yes.” Bingley laughed, a hollow sound entirely devoid of humour. “I watched as Jane’s affections transferred to your cousin. I saw the animation in her expression when speaking with him, the particular smile that once had been reserved for me.”

He rose again, moving restlessly about the room as though physical motion might alleviate the painful recollection. “Even then, I maintained my composure. I had no claim on her, after all. If she preferred the colonel, I would bear it with dignity. But Caroline...”

His expression darkened, a transformation so complete that Darcy found himself instinctively stepping closer to Elizabeth, as though to shield her from the raw emotion emanating from Bingley.

“She mocked me,” Bingley continued, his voice dropping to a harsh whisper.

“At the ball, in front of others, suggesting I had been made a fool of once again. And later, I had imbibed too much brandy, as I think you were aware, Darcy. I knocked on her door before I went to my own bed, perhaps hoping somehow that she had drunk too much wine too, that she would apologise and retract what she had said. But she said...”

He stopped, swallowing hard before continuing.

“She said Jane had never cared for me at all, that any woman of sense would prefer a colonel and an earl’s son to a tradesman’s son playing at being a gentleman.

That I was an embarrassment to her, that we were ‘better off without the chit’ because now perhaps we could return to London and Caroline could find me a wife who would ‘know her place’ and not interfere with her management of our affairs. ”

The raw pain in Bingley’s voice made Darcy wince, yet he maintained his silence, knowing the full story must emerge.

“Something broke in me then,” Bingley admitted, his eyes now fixed on some point in the middle distance, unseeing.

“All the years of submission, of deferring to her judgment, of allowing her to direct my life according to her ambitions... I told her I was done with her interference. That I would marry whom I chose, live where I pleased, and that she was welcome to take her portion and establish her own household if my choices did not suit her.”

He began to tremble visibly. “She laughed, Darcy. Laughed at me and asked what woman would have me without her to guide me through society, to cover my social blunders, to ensure I did not embarrass myself with my ‘puppy-like enthusiasm’ and ‘merchant manners.’”

“And then?” Elizabeth prompted gently when he fell silent again.

“I struck her,” Bingley confessed, the words emerging in a broken sob. “God help me, I struck my own sister. Not with a closed fist, but an open hand across her face. I had never, never raised a hand to a woman before, but in that moment... I simply could not bear another word.”

Darcy felt sick at this confession, yet some distant part of him acknowledged that such provocation might indeed push even a gentle man beyond his limits of restraint.

“Her head snapped back,” Bingley continued, his voice hollow.

“Her nose began to bleed immediately. She staggered away from me, looking so shocked, so... betrayed. I reached for her, to apologise, to help her, but she backed away. She was dazed, confused. She turned too quickly and... and then she was falling. I heard her cry out, heard the terrible sounds as she tumbled down the stairs.”

He covered his face with his hands, his shoulders shaking with silent sobs. “By the time I reached her, she was already gone. Her eyes... her eyes were open, but there was nothing there. No life, no Caroline. Just emptiness.”

In the silence that followed this confession, Darcy found himself unable to speak. The horror of what had occurred, the tragic culmination of years of dysfunctional family dynamics, left him momentarily bereft of words.

“And then?” Elizabeth asked softly, her voice steady despite the obvious distress in her expression.

“I panicked,” Bingley admitted, lowering his hands to reveal a face ravaged by guilt.

“I told myself it was an accident. That I had not meant to hurt her, certainly not to... to kill her. I returned to my chambers, unable to think clearly. When the housemaid found her in the morning, I pretended shock, grief. I have been pretending ever since.”

He looked directly at Darcy then, his eyes pleading for understanding. “I did not mean for her to die, Darcy. I swear it on all I hold sacred. It was a moment’s loss of control after years of submission. A single, terrible moment that cannot be undone.”

Darcy remained silent, processing the full implications of what he had heard.

His friend, the amiable, good-natured man he had known for years, had struck his sister in anger, resulting in her death.

That it had been unintentional did little to mitigate the moral weight of the action, nor the deliberate deception that had followed.

As Bingley collapsed back into his chair, weeping openly now, Darcy exchanged a glance with Elizabeth.

Her eyes reflected his own conflicted emotions: horror at what had transpired, yet a complicated sympathy for the years of manipulation that had preceded this tragedy.

There were no simple judgments to be made here, no clear path forward that would satisfy both justice and mercy.

The confession hung in the air between them, irrevocable and transformative. Whatever came next, nothing would ever be the same for any of them again.

Elizabeth moved first, crossing the room to where Bingley sat crumpled in his chair. She placed a gentle hand on his shoulder, a simple gesture of pure compassion. It was so characteristic of her, Darcy thought. While he remained frozen in indecision, she had found the courage to offer comfort.

“Mr. Bingley,” she said softly, “what happened was terrible, but your remorse is evident.”

Bingley looked up at her touch, his face ravaged by tears, his usual handsome features contorted by grief and shame. “You must despise me,” he whispered. “Both of you. I despise myself.”

“I cannot pretend to understand fully what drove you to such an action,” Elizabeth replied. “Years of manipulation, as you described, may explain your breaking point, though they cannot entirely excuse it.”

Bingley nodded miserably. “I expect you will summon the magistrate now,” he said, addressing Darcy directly. “I shall not resist. Perhaps it is better this way, to have the truth known rather than living with this... this weight upon my soul.”

Darcy found his voice at last, though it emerged rougher than he intended. “The magistrate already suspects the circumstances of Caroline’s death were not as initially reported. It is only a matter of time before the evidence leads him to the same conclusion we reached.”

“I understand,” Bingley said, straightening slightly as though preparing himself for the inevitable. “I shall confess everything to him. It was not premeditated, Darcy. I never intended her harm, but I cannot deny my responsibility for what occurred.”

As Darcy watched Bingley struggle to compose himself, a complex mixture of emotions churned within his breast. Anger at the deception, horror at the violence that had erupted from such an unexpected quarter, yet also sympathy for the years of domination Bingley had described.

Caroline’s manipulations did not justify her brother’s actions, yet they provided a context that could not be entirely dismissed.

Moreover, Darcy could not escape his own culpability in the entire tragic affair.

Had he not interfered in Bingley’s relationship with Jane Bennet a year ago, had he not provided Caroline with the very ammunition she needed to control her brother, perhaps events would have unfolded very differently.

That initial misjudgement had set in motion a chain of circumstances that, while not directly causing Caroline’s death, had contributed to the tension that preceded it.

Elizabeth seemed to sense his internal struggle, for she turned toward him with a questioning gaze. “Fitzwilliam?” she prompted gently. “What are your thoughts on how we should proceed?”

The question forced him to crystallise the half-formed ideas that had been taking shape in his mind.

Justice must be served, yet was there only one form it could take?

If Bingley confessed to the magistrate, he would undoubtedly face trial for manslaughter, if not murder.

The scandal would destroy not only Bingley himself but would cast a shadow over all connected with him.

“Let me think for a moment,” Darcy said, moving toward the window where Bingley had stood earlier.

The grounds of Netherfield spread before him, peaceful and orderly, belying the human tragedy unfolding within its walls.

What was the right course of action? What solution might satisfy the demands of justice while acknowledging the complexities of human failing?

As he stared unseeing at the landscape, a possibility formed in his mind. It was not perfect, perhaps not even entirely honourable, but it offered a path forward that might allow for both consequences and redemption.

Turning back to face the room, Darcy found both Elizabeth and Bingley watching him, though with very different expressions. Elizabeth’s eyes held cautious curiosity, while Bingley’s reflected only despair.

“I believe I have a solution,” Darcy said finally, his voice regaining its customary authority. “One that acknowledges your responsibility, Bingley, while offering you an opportunity to build a different future.”

Bingley straightened slightly, his attention focused entirely on Darcy’s words. “What sort of solution?”