Page 20 of Grade A Girl

Charlie

Ilook past Jaxson and lock eyes with Kade. I expect to see him upset that he wasn’t here, but he’s not. He looks turned on. His eyes are hooded, and he licks his lips slowly like I’m the best-looking meal he’s ever seen.

“You know, if you get her alone, I get her alone, Jaxson.” He smirks from the doorway. He’s in his chef pants and a tight black t-shirt. He looks delicious enough to eat.

“Didn’t expect you here so quickly.” Jaxson smiles back at him before placing my feet on the ground and helping me sit up. He kisses me on the lips and walks to the bathroom to get a towel.

I try to cover my nakedness, but Kade shakes his head, stopping me.God, why is this so hot?I lower my hands again and let him roam his eyes over my body. He licks his lips, and when I peek at his crotch, he is definitely tenting his pants. Jaxson returns and helps me clean up before tossing me a t-shirt to throw on.

Before I have the chance to pull it over my head, Kade is on me. His kisses are hot and passionate, and he trails his fingers over my curves until he reaches my sex. My body hums and I want more. I pull him closer, not letting an inch of space between us, and he chuckles against my lips.

He drops his forehead to mine. “Let’s have dinner and talk. Then you and I are leaving so we can have some alone time.”

“Hey, not fair,” Jaxson calls from the kitchen.

He smirks and turns in Jaxson’s direction. “Maybe you should have kept it in your pants a little longer then,” he calls out, then turns to look at me, “Unless you don’t want to.”

I place my hand on his cheek and smile. “I’d love some one-on-one time.”

Kade helps me pull the t-shirt over my head, and I take a big whiff. It smells like Jaxson, and I smile as he takes my hand and leads me to the table. How the hell did I end up in a situation like this? I look between both of the guys who I have only known for a short while but already can’t see my life without them. Each man brings his own uniqueness to the relationship; where one lacks, the other makes up for.

Kade helps me into my seat. As soon as I’ve taken the first bite, he says, “Tell us what happened?”

Mid-chew, I pull the fork away from my face and place it down in favor of a large gulp of wine.Where do I even begin?

It’s complicated. Kelly and Evan were my best friends in college, and they dumped me like yesterday’s leftovers. I was more upset about losing Kelly in the deal—chicks before dick and all that. I shouldn’t be. Clearly, she didn’t think anything of it, but it still stung. We were friends all through school.

Kelly introduced me to Evan, who was in one of her classes. The three of us became thick as thieves. We did everything together. Evan was hot. There is no doubt about that. With his blond hair, dark brown eyes, and athletic build, he was a dreamboat. Most of the girls on campus wanted him, but he didn’t want anything to do with them.

It was definitely a morale booster knowing he wanted to spend his time with Kelly and me. I was like every other girl—smitten with him. I thought he felt the same, but it turns out, I was wrong.

During a party one night, Evan was feeling me up as I was humping his leg when he told me he wanted to be friends with benefits with me. He then told me he had been hooking up with Kelly the same way for a few months, and she was fine with him sleeping around. That should have been my first clue to cut and run, but I was stupid and horny.

In my drunken haze, I jumped at the chance to be with him. My crush on the sexy guy was going to become a reality. Friends with benefits. How perfect is that? There have been enough movies made to tell me what a horrible idea it was.

He was okay in bed, but he kept calling me Kelly as we were having sex. I felt cheap and dirty, like I was second best. I couldn’t face either of them for a while, and when I finally confronted Kelly about it, she was pissed at me for sleeping with him.

She had no idea about us. He definitely didn’t discuss it with her like he said. She was so blinded by her rage she ended our friendship, and both of them left me high and dry. The rest of the school year was spent with my nose in a textbook. I always knew I was number two in his book, but it killed me to know I was the same to her.

I wring my fingers together as I finish telling them about my past experience. Kade pulls me into his lap and strokes my hair, planting gentle kisses on my forehead. It’s been so many years now, I don’t cry over it, but it still breaks my heart to talk about.

“Charlie, I want you to know neither of us would put you in a situation like that. You’re it for us, if you’ll have us,” Jaxson says as he takes over my seat to rub my back. His words and hands on me are comforting. “You’ve never been second best to us. Even in the short time we’ve known you.”

“I’m sorry for what I said to you, and I’m sorry for the way it came out. After being with you for more than two seconds, I knew you were nothing like Blair, even though you have similar features.” He blushes and buries his head in the crook of my neck.

I run my fingers through his locks and kiss the top of his head. “It’s okay. I’ve gotten over it, but when you told me you asked me out because I look like your ex, it stung and brought up memories I’d rather forget.”

“Let’s finish eating, and then I believe I owe you a lot of make-up sex for being an ass.” Kade smirks and squeezes my bare thigh.

I bite my lower lip and smile but look down. I know Kade said he wanted me alone since Jaxson had me alone, but I really want a night with both of them. Ineedit. “Would it be okay if I have both of you tonight?”

Jaxson and Kade look at one another as large smiles spread across their faces. “Anything you want, babe,” Jaxson says.

I look up at Kade. “I’ll make it up to you, promise.” I kiss him, but when I try to pull back, he keeps me in place, taking a few extra moments to explore my mouth and body. My breathing hitches as he pulls away, and I look between my two sexy men. How is it even possible this is real?

I stand and reach both my hands out for them to take. Each man stands and takes my hand as I lead them toward the bedroom. They stalk toward me, smiles on their faces. In a few more minutes, I’m not going to have control of the situation, but for now, I can show them how much they mean to me.

I pull Kade’s lips back down to mine and press my body into his as I pull Jaxson closer behind me. I want to feel them worshipping me. Not because I think I’m a queen or anything, but because I want them to understand exactly how they make me feel.

Jaxson’s lips are on my neck and shoulders as he moves across my back. His rough fingers dance across my skin, and he presses his bulge into my ass. I moan into Kade’s mouth, relishing in the feel of both men on me.

Jaxson runs his fingers over my bare ass and presses his thumb against my puckered hole. I automatically clench my muscles, not used to the foreign feeling. “Has anyone ever had your ass before, Charlie?” he husks in my ear. He moves his thumb away, and I want it back.

I shake my head and gasp when Kade nips at my ear, his hand around my throat, exposing me to him. “Do you want us buried deep in your ass?” Kade asks.

“Yes,” I whimper as Jaxson brings his wet thumb back to my hole and gentle presses again.

“Relax, Charlie,” Jaxson coos as Kade distracts me with his roaming hands. He finds my clit and starts to rub as Jaxson presses past the ring of muscles. Kade doesn’t stop moving his hand until I’m bucking my hips back and forth on him. They both pull away suddenly, and I pop my eyes open in shock.

“Get the plug,” Kade says.