Page 49 of Another Chance

“I just got tested,” Theo admitted, which was news to Eric. He hadn’t even known this was on the table, but he couldn’t say that he objected, either. “I’m clean. So, if you want …”

“Yes.” Eric didn’t even hesitate. Not for a moment. He couldn’t have been more interested, and for their very first time this way for them, he was glad it would be bare, skin to skin.

“Okay.” Theo clearly had some nerves, from the way he had to force himself to relax as he lay back, the slight hesitation before he spread his legs. “Then show me what it’s like.”

Eric took great pleasure in ignoring the condom, but he plucked the lube from the table and opened the packet. Using about half of it, he coated his fingers and dribbled the rest, shining, shimmering slick droplets, between Theo’s legs.

It was tempting to rush. It had been so long since he’d been with another man like this, so long since he’d fucked anyone, and he was more than ready to break that streak. But this was also going to be Theo’s introduction to this act, and he was determined to make it good.

So he took his time, pushing a finger in, hissing at the tight pull, the squeeze, of his fiancé’s gorgeous body around it. Watching Theo’s face, he watched until the slight twinge of discomfort that he saw there disappeared, and only then did he ease it in just a little further.

Until, that is, Eric was deep enough that he could find what he was looking for. When he felt that sensitive gland, he pressed his fingertip directly on it and rubbed, and Theo gave a sudden, hoarse scream and his whole body clenched up.

“Mmm, it’s good, right?” Eric murmured and then wrapped his mouth around the head of Theo’s cock, glad to find that he was leaking all over himself, tasting of his addictive, salty sweet precum.

“So good, Eric, please,” Theo moaned, and Eric would have grinned if his mouth hadn’t been stuffed full of cock. Theo so easily made Eric lose all control, and it was deeply gratifying to be able to do the same to him.

Soon, he had two fingers inside of Theo, who was nice and slick with the lube which Eric had spread everywhere. He looked up, watching, waiting, enjoying the flush of color on Theo’s cheeks, the way those beautiful lips of his parted with his panted breath.

“Please. Now, Eric. Now, baby,” Theo whispered, and Eric would have had to be stupid, not to mention heartless, to turn him down. He had been ignoring, as best he could, his own throbbing cock and balls, but only with great effort.

Pulling away, Eric kept on sucking at the head of his cock, keeping him worked up and right on the edge, as he slid his fingers from that impossibly tight ass. It took him only a second to get the rest of the lube in the packet onto his own erection, making it slippery, making him hiss as his fingers passed over the sensitive, swollen flesh.

Once he was prepared, he finally raised his head and looked up into Theo’s eyes. Easing on top of him, he had to wonder if this was real, if it could possibly be real. Things this good just didn’t happen to him, and yet, by all appearances, it seemed that was exactly what had happened.

“Fuck me,” Theo insisted, with so much passion in his voice, so much need, that Eric’s body clenched and he could almost just come right then and there. Instead, he took a deep breath, just to bring himself down a tiny bit, and then only when he was ready, only when he thought that he could do it without shooting himself right over the edge into orgasm, did he lean in and kiss Theo and then, for the first time, slip inside of him.

Eric could still remember how good Theo had made it on their first time together, and it was a damn good thing, because when he felt the tight clench of his muscles around him, when he felt the slickness seeming to welcome him in, to pull him further inside, he could have shot off right away. But thinking about how Theo had focused on him, on how perfect his first time had been, helped him hold back.

He was going to make Theo’s first time every bit as good.

For a while, he just focused on kissing, tongues slipping together, mouths open to each other, lips and breath tangling in a deeply intimate dance. Theo had tensed up a bit when he was taken, but slowly, bit by bit, his shoulders relaxed and he let Eric in a little bit more.

It took some patience, but the reward was there when Eric looked down into Theo’s eyes and realized that he was fully inside of him, buried to the hilt, and that Theo, from the glazed look in his eyes and the blissed-out expression on his face, was feeling no pain.

“Can I move now, Teddy?” Eric whispered, and Theo gave him an utterly stunning little grin and nodded his head, and Eric did start to move, at the same time as Theo did.

There was no chance that Eric wouldn’t come. The issue, rather, was holding it off until he could make sure that Theo felt it, too. They found that perfect rhythm, hips pumping, clutching at each other, kissing over and over as Eric sought out the exact perfect angle.

When he found it, he knew. Theo suddenly let out one of those gorgeous little cries that Eric had learned he only did when he was really excited, when he was feeling good, and Theo’s movements under him started to get just a little bit sloppy, fast and erratic.

Seeing Theo like this, Eric couldn’t help but fall in love with him more than ever. He smiled down at him and met his eager thrusts, both of them getting faster, and even though Eric knew that this pace was going to make him come, it was okay, because Theo was obviously right there, too.

It hit them both together. Right when Eric was sure that it was over, that he couldn’t hold back even a split second longer, Theo cried out his name and Eric, who had been reaching for his cock to help him along, got to watch in amazement as Theo twitched and, untouched, his dick shot all over itself, pearly white covering him and splashing onto his stomach in glistening droplets.

“Oh fuck, Teddy,” Eric whispered, and the sight of that beautiful long cock covered in Theo’s own fluids was just too much for him. He let out a desperate growl of his own as his cum spurted inside the other man, as he filled him up for the first time.

“Eric. Goddamn, I love you,” Theo whispered, barely audible over his panting breath except that Eric heard him perfectly. For a moment, he just let himself rest on the large, warm, sated body beneath him, head on Theo’s shoulder, clinging to him like he might just float right away if he didn’t.

He sort of felt like that, anyway.

“Love you too, Teddy,” Eric whispered and then closed his eyes and just basked in the realization that he could stay right where he was forever. This was his fiancé, his family, his everything.

And now, though he honestly never could have seen it coming, he never would have thought, in their eight years apart, that it could happen, he had Theo, and Theo had him.

Forever.

THE END