Page 16 of A Very Knotty Halloween (Knotty Holiday #1)

I empty inside of her pussy, but I’m not done with her yet.

I glance at Cas, and as he sits back, he nods, signifying he’s on the same wavelength as me.

I pull out of her core and scoop some of her slick with my fingers.

I know there’s a bottle of lube nearby, but I’d much rather use her slick for what it was meant to be used for.

Slick is delicious, but it’s also natural lubrication, meant to help omegas not feel pain when they’re being knotted—and as a result of that pain-dulling, it’s also perfect lubrication for a different hole.

“Jack, you want to help me tag-team her?” I cock a brow to the alpha who, up until now, has been waiting patiently at the foot of the bed, and the moment I say it, he leaps into action, more than ready to fuck her again.

As am I. As. Am. I.

“Jack,” I take the lead, “lay down on your back. Marnie, straddle him, take him inside you.” I watch as neither of them argue, as they both do what I instructed.

I don’t often get to give orders, that honor goes to our pack leader, but when I do, I always get this excited feeling deep in my gut, like I’m doing exactly what I was meant to.

Jack hurriedly lays on his back, and Marnie crawls on top of him, every inch of her beautiful body on display. She straddles him, one leg on either side of him, and she slowly sinks down on his hard, waiting cock. Once he’s inside, they both moan, and she naturally begins to rock her hips.

“Hold on,” I say, taking her by the back of the neck with my slick-free hand and pushing her down, so that her chest lays against Jack’s. “Not quite yet, omega.” I get in position behind her, spread those perfect ass cheeks, and lube up her ass.

Cas says, “Relax. Damien and Jack will take care of you.”

“Mm-hmm. We will,” I agree, and once her ass is sufficiently lubed-up, I guide my cock to her tight, waiting hole. “I’ll go slow, baby. Ease you into it. Don’t tense up. Just relax and let it happen, and Jack and I will blow your mind.”

For obvious reasons, Jack and I fucking the same girl together has been a fantasy of mine for years now. I just never thought… well, I didn’t know it’d happen tonight, that it’d feel this right, but I’m more than okay with it.

I do wish these goddamn collars weren’t on our necks, but I understand the necessity of them.

My tip presses against her tight hole, and I say again, “Relax. Breathe out.” I like to go hard, but not when it’ll hurt her. Not now. Not when her body isn’t used to having a cock in both holes at once.

Marnie listens. She doesn’t fight, doesn’t argue.

She lets out a long breath, relaxing on top of Jack’s chest, and I start to push inside her.

It’s a slow process, and I don’t rush it.

My cock is nothing to laugh at, so it isn’t simple like a butt plug.

It takes more time to get that ass adjusted to my girth.

Bit by bit, I push inside her, filling up her ass with my length. Her hole is tight around me, so goddamned tight, and I shudder in spite of myself, even though I’m not as deep as I’d like to be. I move so slowly I nearly drive myself mad, but the last thing I want to do is hurt this girl.

Because Cas is right. She’s ours. Ours to fuck, ours to take care of, ours to love.

“Look at you,” Cas praises her as I keep pushing inside her, “taking two cocks at once. Your body was made for this, omega. You’re doing such a good job. You’re being such a good girl for us.”

The dirty talk and praise is the key to help keeping her relaxed, apparently, because she lets out another deep breath, and the rim of her ass loosens just a bit, allowing me to push deep inside of her.

Jack must feel the pressure too, because he moans and shuts his eyes, losing himself to the sensation.

“Goddamn,” I murmur once I’m fully inside. I don’t rock my hips right away; I remain with my cock nestled in her ass, letting her body get used to being doubly full. I’d bet anything this little omega never thought this was how tonight would end up. “I could get used to this.”

And, if I have my way—if we have our way—I will. This won’t be a one-night kind of deal. This will be something we can do whenever the hell we want, anytime we want.

Cas speaks, “How does it feel to have two cocks buried in you?” His voice is so low it makes the omega between me and Jack shiver, and her asshole tighten just a bit, but then she relaxes, her body humming.

“I bet it feels good. I bet you never want out of that sandwich.” He smirks at that, and his eyes meet mine.

He gives me a short nod, and I begin to gyrate my hips.

Fucking her ass isn’t quite like fucking her pussy.

There’s more resistance, a tighter fit, and the ever-present awareness that if I go too hard, too fast, I’ll hurt her.

I’m dying to knot her, and keeping that instinct buried down is a constant struggle.

Still, somehow I manage to keep my cock knot-free as I fuck that tight hole.

Beneath her, I can feel Jack’s hips move as much as they can, given his position.

His ass lifts from the bed as he works to plunge his cock in and out of her core.

Together, we fuck her silly. Together, with both of our cocks deep inside of her, we make her come, and as that fresh slick fills the air, we fuck her harder.

It’s easy to lose your mind when she’s there. I had no idea it would feel this… this right.

Cas’s chest grumbles with what I can only describe as hunger the moment her fresh slick fills the air.

He positions himself above Jack’s head, his knees on either side of him, apparently no longer content with just watching.

He kneels there, knees spread, and he grabs the back of Marnie’s head, tugging her head back.

“Open that mouth,” Cas orders her. “I want every hole on your body full of us, omega.” All growly, even though he doesn’t use his alpha dominance, what other choice does the omega between us have?

She can only listen, and though I can’t see her face, I know she parts her lips for him, because soon after that he pushes his cock into her mouth—and just like that, we take our omega together, all three of us, each of us filling a hole on her beautiful body up.

Jack in her pussy, me in her ass, and Cas in her mouth.

We work in sync, the three of us fucking our chosen hole and chasing our own orgasms.

And Marnie? She doesn’t resist. Doesn’t fight. She has no complaints at all. It’s like she’s more than willing to be ours; the four of us are on the same wavelength and it is utterly delicious.

Due to how tight her little ass is, I erupt first, grunting and groaning as I let her ass milk me for all I’m worth. I slam into her from behind, my cock spewing its seed into her backside, the pleasure in me so overpowering I immediately feel weak.

Beneath her, Jack must share my pleasure, because the alpha comes almost simultaneously with me. He jerks harder into her core, his moan so loud it bounces around in the air. He comes inside of her with short pumps of his cock, his hands finding mine on her hips, our fingertips touching.

Not going to lie, it’s sexy as hell to fuck the same omega together. Honestly, I could keep going. I could go again and again and again. Who needs a break? Who needs sleep? Who needs snacks and hydration? Marnie has everything I need.

Cas tells me, “Go clean yourself up and get the tub running.” Apparently we’re moving this party to the tub, which I’m more than fine with.

I withdraw from her ass slowly—don’t want to move too fast, for reasons I don’t want to describe.

Let’s just say when it comes to ass play, slow is always better.

Once I’m out of her, I go to the bathroom and clean myself up, making sure to lather around all the nooks and crannies before washing myself off.

Then I go to fill the tub while Cas is still busy fucking her mouth with vigor.

Hmm. Seems the omega can take our alpha a bit deeper than she could earlier. She’s learning already. A quick study. That’s a good sign—although, I suppose things like that must come naturally to omegas.

Once I get the water to a nice, warm temperature, I return to the bathroom and grab a bottle of bubble bath liquid and dump the whole thing in—and immediately, lots of bubbles start forming, and I stand there and wonder if, perhaps, I shouldn’t have poured the entire bottle in.

I peer at the instructions and see that, yep, I should’ve only poured a cap’s worth in.

I mean… the tub is huge, made for multiple people, so one cap wouldn’t nearly be enough. One cap would be for a regular tub, right?

Oops.

Whatever. Doesn’t really matter. I’m sure it’ll be fine.

Spoiler alert: it is not fine.